Review Silent Hill Townfall
4
5
46 ratings

Review Silent Hill Townfall

Date: (Last saved review: ) - Review:

Check all the 60 reviews find on Video Games Silent Hill Townfall, with the 46 ratings, comments, pros & cons from the reviewers.
Theses reviews and tests from Video Games magazines and websites give 46 ratings, we get this average rating to this Silent Hill product : 4/5.

En bref
  • 60 reviews and opinions with 46 ratings for Silent Hill Townfall
  • We obtain an average score of 4/5, or 80.37/100
  • NDA on Reviews ? Please note that 31 reviews were published the same day 21/09/2026.

Silent Hill Townfall ratings

46 Ratings ranked from best to worst, green to good grades, red to bad, Average rating: 4/5.
Source: https://www.commentChoisir.fr
  5/5  TechPowerUp  91/100  COGconnected  9/10  Numerama
  9/10  TheSixthAxis  90/100  Gaming Trend  9/10  Pizza Fria
  9/10  GamingBolt  9/10  Xbox-Mag  89/100  PCGamer
  87/100  VideogiochItalia  85/100  TierraGamer  85/100  Console Tribe
  8/10  GameKult.com  4/5  EuroGamer.fr  8/10  Journal du Geek
  8/10  IGN  4/5  GamesRadar  4/5  Absolute Geeks
  8/10  Shacknews  8/10  Press Start  8/10  GameInformer
  8/10  PCGames  4/5  Geeks By Girls  8/10  Areajugones
  8/10  Multiplayer.it  8/10  GameWave  16/20  GamerGen
  8/10  VideoChums  8/10  NerdMovieProductions  8/10  GameOver
  8/10  ZTGD  8/10  Coplanet  8/10  HeartBits VG
  8/10  Le Bêta-Testeur  8/10  GameHope  8/10  Niche Gamer
  8/10  GameScore.it  8/10  DisplayWeb  7/10  ActuGaming
  7/10  Try a Game  7/10  Beyond Gaming  70/100  JVFrance
  6/10  GamersGlobal  6/10  XBoxEra  6/10  wccftech
12 Preview or review without rating: GameBlog.fr, GameSpot, 4players, Push Square, Game IT, TechRaptor, NME, MeuPlayStation, JeuxVideo.com, GamesWelt, FactorNews.com, The Pixel Post

For Video Games, ratings are sometimes different depending on the platform. Please refer to the good review...

Pros and cons for Silent Hill Townfall List of reviews and ratings

To better compare, we looked for you the advantages and disadvantages of Below and the notes given by specialized sites.


5
5
TechPowerUp
reviewed at 24/09/2026 - [read the full review on TechPowerUp]
91
100
COGconnected
Silent Hill Townfall reviewed by COGconnected
Review Silent Hill Townfall by COGconnected
Suffocating Atmosphere
Feeling Vulnerable
Puzzle Design
Art Direction
Combat Not As Visceral
Enemy Variety
[91/100] reviewed at 21/09/2026 - Test Silent Hill: Townfall ? A New Perspective on Fear [read the full review on COGconnected]
reviewed at 22/09/2026 - Test Silent Hill: Townfall Video ? A New Perspective on Fear [read the full review on COGconnected]
9
10
Numerama
Silent Hill Townfall reviewed by Numerama
Review Silent Hill Townfall by Numerama
Surprisingly diverse and rhythmic
Creative and surprising
Great artistic direction
Not crazy fights
Scenario a bit too obvious
Fairly punitive infiltration
reviewed at 21/09/2026 - [read the full review on Numerama]
9
10
TheSixthAxis
Silent Hill Townfall reviewed by TheSixthAxis
Review Silent Hill Townfall by TheSixthAxis
Meaningfully explores the Silent Hill lore
Stress and tension of avoiding and fighting monsters
Excellently captures the Scottish setting
Rewards multiple playthroughs
One obtuse puzzle that spoiled the flow
A Scottish main character would have been nice
Breakable weapons are always divisive
reviewed at 21/09/2026 - [read the full review on TheSixthAxis]
90
100
Gaming Trend
Silent Hill Townfall reviewed by Gaming Trend
Review Silent Hill Townfall by Gaming Trend
Authentic, desolate atmosphere
Excellent storytelling
Immersive puzzles
NG
+ with multiple endings
Great DualSense features
Enemy AI a bit too sensitive
Some sections are dragged out
Hard crashes
reviewed at 21/09/2026 - [read the full review on Gaming Trend]
9
10
Pizza Fria
Silent Hill Townfall reviewed by Pizza Fria
Review Silent Hill Townfall by Pizza Fria
Localized subtitles for Brazilian Portuguese.
Extremely captivating story filled with symbolism.
Smart puzzles, with adjustable difficulty.
Psychological terror worthy of the best Silent Hill.
Even with help, some more complex puzzles can discourage casual players.
Not much variety of enemies.
reviewed at 21/09/2026 - [read the full review on Pizza Fria]
9
10
GamingBolt
Silent Hill Townfall reviewed by GamingBolt
Review Silent Hill Townfall by GamingBolt
Excellent story, backed by strong pacing, nuanced writing, and wonderful performances
St. Amelia is an excellent setting and boasts wonderfully dreadful atmosphere
Tense combat and stealth
Strong puzzle design
CRTV adds a unique layer to puzzles and stealth
Tactile, diegetic UI helps make the world feel more grounded
Strong audio and visual design.
Exploration doesn?t always feel appropriately rewarding
Level design can be a bit too straightforward at times
Disappointingly limited in enemy variety.
reviewed at 21/09/2026 - [read the full review on GamingBolt]
9
10
Xbox-Mag
Silent Hill Townfall reviewed by Xbox-Mag
Review Silent Hill Townfall by Xbox-Mag
Sumptuous music;
Delicious atmosphere;
Well-crafted story;
Strong themes;
Technically flawless;
Top-notch artistic direction;
Five endings;
Immersive point of view;
Well done CRTV.
Act 3 is partly frustrating and annoying;
Classic handling;
Sometimes complex and poorly presented puzzles;
Grey artistic direction.
reviewed at 03/10/2026 - [read the full review on Xbox-Mag]
89
100
PCGamer
reviewed at 21/09/2026 - [read the full review on PCGamer]
87
100
VideogiochItalia
Silent Hill Townfall reviewed by VideogiochItalia
Review Silent Hill Townfall by VideogiochItalia
Finally a real Silent Hill
Excellent enemy design
Original and sometimes really stimulating riddles.
Claustrophobic atmospheres and tension always palpable
Aunt, many references to the historical chapters of the saga and to P.T.
The combat system is very basic.
Some moments can be frustrating due to an enemy AI that is not really brilliant.
85
100
TierraGamer
reviewed at 21/09/2026 - [read the full review on TierraGamer]
85
100
Console Tribe
Silent Hill Townfall reviewed by Console Tribe
Review Silent Hill Townfall by Console Tribe
Atmosphere consistent with the best episodes of the series.
Well-calibrated scenario
CRTV, well-implemented fights and puzzles
Some moments of stealth a little too insistent
Final brain puzzle
Bestiary and boss fights reduced to a minimum
reviewed at 21/09/2026 - [read the full review on Console Tribe]
8
10
GameKult.com
Silent Hill Townfall reviewed by GameKult.com
Review Silent Hill Townfall by GameKult.com
Rare immersion quality, St. Amelia appears to be directly drawn from reality.
What the hell is that!
A survival horror game that instills fear through its mechanics and not just its presentation.
An interesting and refreshing story for the saga.
Well-crafted puzzles, neither too easy nor too obscure.
We want to come back (for the different endings and for the unsolved mysteries)
When the game returns to cliché survival-horror, the mechanics struggle.
Writing that relies too heavily on what is left unsaid to be truly effective
reviewed at 21/09/2026 - [read the full review on GameKult.com]
4
5
EuroGamer.fr
reviewed at 21/09/2026 - [read the full review on EuroGamer.fr]
8
10
Journal du Geek
Silent Hill Townfall reviewed by Journal du Geek
Review Silent Hill Townfall by Journal du Geek
A masterful retro 1996 atmosphere
+ The CRTV is an excellent idea
The first person view that intensifies fear and claustrophobia
Well-crafted riddles
Technically neat
Five endings and a real interest in replaying for a New Game Plus.
Only 35 euros on e-commerce platforms
Heavy and frankly not very dynamic fights
A bestiary with a design too ordinary for the saga
8
10
IGN
reviewed at 21/09/2026 - [read the full review on IGN]
4
5
GamesRadar
Silent Hill Townfall reviewed by GamesRadar
Review Silent Hill Townfall by GamesRadar
+
Properly scary
+
Fantastic atmosphere and looks
+
Brilliant sound design
+
Compelling story to unravel
-
Wearingly stealth heavy
-
Limited enemy variation
reviewed at 21/09/2026 - [read the full review on GamesRadar]
4
5
Absolute Geeks
8
10
Shacknews
Silent Hill Townfall reviewed by Shacknews
Review Silent Hill Townfall by Shacknews
Great puzzle design
Immersive world design
Simon is a great protagonist
Solid scares
Bland combat
Enemy behavior isn't always logical
reviewed at 01/01/1970 - [read the full review on Shacknews]
8
10
Press Start
Silent Hill Townfall reviewed by Press Start
Review Silent Hill Townfall by Press Start
Very strong world design and atmosphere
Classic feeling mix of stealth and action horror
Intriguing story that engages from beginning to end
Incredibly strong puzzle design
Monster design and variety is disappointing
Lacking super strong and intense horror of previous games
Undercooked use of the CRT mechanics
Limited to no connections to wider Silent Hill lore
reviewed at 21/09/2026 - [read the full review on Press Start]
8
10
GameInformer
reviewed at 21/09/2026 - [read the full review on GameInformer]
8
10
PCGames
reviewed at 21/09/2026 - [read the full review on PCGames]
4
5
Geeks By Girls
Silent Hill Townfall reviewed by Geeks By Girls
Review Silent Hill Townfall by Geeks By Girls
Saint Amelia, a credible, stunning Scottish setting that is very pleasant to explore.
A perfectly exploited subjective view
Different points of view on the story that do not break the immersion.
Some beautiful staging finds
Very nice to see and hear
A beautiful lifespan
Too forced and painful back and forth trips in the long run
Some puzzles and laborious manipulations
The CRT is a good idea, but clearly underutilized.
A famished bestiary
Lack of a memorable musical theme
Not necessarily very accessible even in easy mode
8
10
Areajugones
Silent Hill Townfall reviewed by Areajugones
Review Silent Hill Townfall by Areajugones
The atmosphere of St. Amelia, simply perfect.
Two playable protagonists with intertwining stories.
The CRTV, a mechanism that grips and utilizes the DualSense
Satisfying puzzles that don't hold your hand
A story full of intrigue that invites you to keep discovering.
Artistic direction and soundtrack that are equally frightening and captivating.
The brutal fighting may shock those who are not familiar with the saga.
Artificial intelligence detects you too quickly in certain areas.
The creatures achieve without reaching the level of classics.
reviewed at 21/09/2026 - [read the full review on Areajugones]
8
10
Multiplayer.it
Silent Hill Townfall reviewed by Multiplayer.it
Review Silent Hill Townfall by Multiplayer.it
So many surprises, it's a Silent Hill that reinvents itself constantly.
Oppressive atmosphere, at times it's very scary.
Some puzzles related to devices are awesome
It takes a few hours to start.
Stealth is simple, sometimes not very exciting.
This can be frustrating and difficult to read at times.
8
10
GameWave
Silent Hill Townfall reviewed by GameWave
Review Silent Hill Townfall by GameWave
The use of black bars magnificently enhances the cinematic aspect and immersion.
+ A sumptuous artistic direction and a striking Scottish island setting (St. Amelia).
+ The gradual rise of fear, carried by exceptional sound design.
+ The choice of the first-person view enhances the feeling of isolation and tension.
+ Gameplay that intelligently favors escape and discretion over heavy action.
+ The changes in narrative perspective effectively renew the infiltration mechanics.
The handling of the CRTV can sometimes be confusing to accurately locate threats.
Some FPS drops observed in the most demanding outdoor areas.
A final third of the adventure that drags on with some repetitive back and forth.
reviewed at 21/09/2026 - [read the full review on GameWave]
16
20
GamerGen
Silent Hill Townfall reviewed by GamerGen
Review Silent Hill Townfall by GamerGen
The atmosphere, oppressive The first-person view, perfect for immersion Infiltration, perfectly suited for horror The CRTV, an excellent gameplay idea The puzzles, brilliant and rewarding Multiple playable characters and multiple endings The sound atmosphere, spot on
Some areas lack variety A fairly limited variety of enemies One or two particularly twisted puzzles Weapons that break can be divisive No French dubbing, too bad...
reviewed at 01/01/1970 - [read the full review on GamerGen]
8
10
VideoChums
Silent Hill Townfall reviewed by VideoChums
Review Silent Hill Townfall by VideoChums
Cinematic visuals and otherworldly analogies really make the haunting tale hit home
Well-implemented first-person perspective
Stealth parts are incredibly intense and fun
Some puzzles are way too confusing
Certain segments need more checkpoints
You'll wander around a lot throughout
reviewed at 22/09/2026 - [read the full review on VideoChums]
8
10
NerdMovieProductions
Silent Hill Townfall reviewed by NerdMovieProductions
Review Silent Hill Townfall by NerdMovieProductions
Excellent horror atmosphere,
Stealth dynamics add a new dimension to the Silent Hill series.
Riddles and exploration at the service of narrative coherence.
Visually, the game attracts with its frightening and terrifying visuals.
We could have done more in terms of the variety of enemies.
The combat system remains simple and sketchy.
If you do not follow the path of discretion, some passages are too difficult.
8
10
GameOver
Silent Hill Townfall reviewed by GameOver
Review Silent Hill Townfall by GameOver
Well-written plot and characters.
Artistic interpretation that corresponds to the style of the series.
Excellent audio sector.
A minimal variety of enemies.
Stealth at times creates fatigue.
The last section.
reviewed at 29/09/2026 - [read the full review on GameOver]
8
10
ZTGD
Silent Hill Townfall reviewed by ZTGD
Review Silent Hill Townfall by ZTGD
Great characters and story
Moody atmosphere
CRT mechanic is great
Clunky combat
Difficulty spike later in the game
reviewed at 30/09/2026 - [read the full review on ZTGD]
8
10
Coplanet
Silent Hill Townfall reviewed by Coplanet
Review Silent Hill Townfall by Coplanet
Back to the origins
First person widely promoted
Original and brilliant riddles...
Good longevity and replayability
Too many enemies at certain stages
Stiff melee attacks
... but some a little frustrating
reviewed at 28/09/2026 - [read the full review on Coplanet]
8
10
HeartBits VG
Silent Hill Townfall reviewed by HeartBits VG
Review Silent Hill Townfall by HeartBits VG
The sound design is very good.
The riddles have a good level of challenge.
The development of the story does not decrease.
The struggle can feel very brutal.
Backtrack
reviewed at 07/10/2026 - [read the full review on HeartBits VG]
8
10
Le Bêta-Testeur
8
10
GameHope
Silent Hill Townfall reviewed by GameHope
Review Silent Hill Townfall by GameHope
A perfect atmosphere
The riddles
A welcome renewal
Beautiful environments even though they are scary
An uninspired bestiary
Some guidance issues
A few back and forths
[8/10] reviewed at 08/10/2026 - Silent Hill : Townfall (PS5) [read the full review on GameHope]
[8/10] reviewed at 08/10/2026 - Silent Hill : Townfall (PC) [read the full review on GameHope]
8
10
Niche Gamer
Silent Hill Townfall reviewed by Niche Gamer
Review Silent Hill Townfall by Niche Gamer
Hellishly tricky puzzles and tense situations
Absolutely amazing visuals and atmosphere
Good acting and sound design
The portable TV mechanic is smartly used in puzzles
Stressful stealth, claustrophobic environment, and tight resources
Some of the enemy designs are kind of weak
Too many decorative doors that look like you can open them but can't
No progression system and easily exploitable difficulty
Some assets are noticeably recycled around
reviewed at 06/10/2026 - [read the full review on Niche Gamer]
8
10
GameScore.it
Silent Hill Townfall reviewed by GameScore.it
Review Silent Hill Townfall by GameScore.it
Extraordinary atmosphere, with a captivating Scottish setting and remarkable audiovisual quality.
Captivating and mystery-rich storytelling, capable of tackling mature themes while maintaining a strong sense of curiosity.
Original and well-contextualized puzzles, perfectly integrated into the story and exploration.
Stealth sections are sometimes frustrating, mainly due to the unbalanced AI of certain enemies.
Some puzzles are excessively complex, which may disrupt the flow of the adventure.
Some technical uncertainties with the standard PS5, including occasional frame rate drops and stability issues.
reviewed at 12/10/2026 - [read the full review on GameScore.it]
8
10
DisplayWeb
reviewed at 24/10/2026 - [read the full review on DisplayWeb]
7
10
ActuGaming
Silent Hill Townfall reviewed by ActuGaming
Review Silent Hill Townfall by ActuGaming
A first person view that works
Music and sound design
Riddles that are mostly well-crafted
All integrated analog components
A perfectly controlled atmosphere
A story with a slightly too visible plot
The "specifications" aspect
Some rigidities
Characters who lack a bit of depth
Bestiary very (too?) homogeneous
reviewed at 21/09/2026 - [read the full review on ActuGaming]
7
10
Try a Game
Silent Hill Townfall reviewed by Try a Game
Review Silent Hill Townfall by Try a Game
The graphic and sound atmosphere is there.
Enhancing immersion through first-person view
A multi-level scenario
The usual multiple endings
Gender stereotypes
The infiltration phases are somewhat random in their resolution.
PC: keyboard controls
A decrease in quality and pace in Act 3.
reviewed at 29/09/2026 - [read the full review on Try a Game]
7
10
Beyond Gaming
Silent Hill Townfall reviewed by Beyond Gaming
Review Silent Hill Townfall by Beyond Gaming
Interesting story...
Beautifully crafted Scottish frame
Strong atmosphere and excellent audiovisual design
Very strong and challenging puzzles.
even if the plot is a bit predictable
Stealth is underdeveloped
Instant elimination enemies remain particularly irritating.
reviewed at 07/10/2026 - [read the full review on Beyond Gaming]
70
100
JVFrance
Silent Hill Townfall reviewed by JVFrance
Review Silent Hill Townfall by JVFrance
An overall polished art direction
The CRTV, an original mechanic that integrates smartly with exploration, puzzles, and storytelling
A minimalist but effective soundtrack that contributes to the overall unease
A convincing English and Japanese voice-over
A relatively accessible adventure, with a decent lifespan and multiple endings
A game that focuses more on storytelling than on fear, which may disappoint fans of more intense horror.
Unconvincing fights
Imperfect stealth that can become repetitive
A relatively limited bestiary
Some pacing issues, especially when the game stretches certain exploration phases
Imperfect PC optimization, with stuttering and fluidity issues that may harm immersion
reviewed at 09/10/2026 - [read the full review on JVFrance]
6
10
GamersGlobal
Silent Hill Townfall reviewed by GamersGlobal
Review Silent Hill Townfall by GamersGlobal
Control with the mouse and keyboard generally works well...
Operate individual keys on analog equipment
Three levels of difficulty and a hint mode for the puzzles.
Good volume with 10 to 15 hours of gameplay, multiple endings, and New Game
+ mode.
Challenging riddles, sometimes using 90s technology.
Mysteriously staged story, not too cryptic.
Exploration gradually opens up areas, while new dangers maintain the tension.
A certain element acts as a constant during a game over.
A very detailed and carefully crafted set.
Great fog effects
The soundtrack hits just right in the calm scenes as well as in moments of danger.
Terrifying monster noises
An immersive sound atmosphere
Good speaker in English
Translation in English:
Correct German translation, although not perfect.
...but the inventory on I is not perfect and cannot be closed with ESC.
No manipulation of the keys of analog devices in the game with the mouse.
The respective movement patterns or detection by monsters are not always easily understandable.
Even in story mode, a certain Stalker kills immediately.
A type of opponent can repeatedly strike the game character in a very short amount of time with a powerful grip.
Sometimes automatic backups are rather rare.
Some passages will remove your weapons, wallhack-CRTV, and continuation items.
Monster design mainly not exciting
Sometimes, short image glitches, even in cutscenes.
reviewed at 21/09/2026 - [read the full review on GamersGlobal]
6
10
XBoxEra
Silent Hill Townfall reviewed by XBoxEra
Review Silent Hill Townfall by XBoxEra
Solid Vibes
Stellar Graphics
Poor Combat
Boring Enemies
reviewed at 21/09/2026 - [read the full review on XBoxEra]
6
10
wccftech
Silent Hill Townfall reviewed by wccftech
Review Silent Hill Townfall by wccftech
A solid typical Silent Hill yarn
Varied, inventive level design
Can be pretty nerve-wracking
Clever, challenging puzzles
Fairly substantial campaign
Story a bit too typical ultimately
Frustrating, tiresome stealth
Starts out on a bad foot
Forgettable soundtrack
Limited reasons to replay
reviewed at 24/09/2026 - [read the full review on wccftech]
-
GameBlog.fr
reviewed at 21/09/2026 - [read the full review on GameBlog.fr]
-
GameSpot
reviewed at 21/09/2026 - [read the full review on GameSpot]
-
4players
A captivating and always surprising story
Successful narrative structure, skillfully intertwining individual fragments.
Fun stealth mechanics with CRTV and Pager
The level design enhances stealth and increases tension.
Dynamic puzzles put me in danger.
Satisfying and sometimes challenging puzzle design
A little more action in the sequel of the game, without compromising its identity.
Disturbing sound atmosphere
A stylish look with a strong use of the color red.
The first section with the damn meatball
A little too long
Little variability in opponents
Too many air duct mazes
The second part with the damn meatball
reviewed at 21/09/2026 - Silent Hill Townfall im Test: Packender Survival-Horror mit einem frustrierenden Problem [read the full review on 4players]
reviewed at 22/09/2026 - Silent Hill Townfall im Test: Ein starker Horror-Hit ? aber einen Aspekt hätte ich wirklich nicht gebraucht [read the full review on 4players]
-
Push Square
reviewed at 21/09/2026 - [read the full review on Push Square]
-
Game IT
reviewed at 21/09/2026 - [read the full review on Game IT]
-
TechRaptor
reviewed at 15/09/2026 - [read the full review on TechRaptor]
-
NME
A gorgeously creepy and realistic folk horror setting
The first-person perspective adds immersion
With its unkillable, stalking boss-beast hunting you down through several segments, fans desperate for an Alien: Isolation sequel will essentially find one here
Puzzles, while satisfying when they click, can be overly cryptic or feel like on-the-hoof work experience training
Too good to be this short
reviewed at 21/09/2026 - [read the full review on NME]
-
MeuPlayStation
-
JeuxVideo.com
reviewed at 24/09/2026 - [read the full review on JeuxVideo.com]
-
GamesWelt
An exceptional atmosphere of horror
CRTV is a creative and versatile mechanism.
Powerful sound design
Interesting topics around guilt and responsibility
The fights remain deliberately resource-poor and tense.
Some mysteries are unnecessarily cryptic.
The selection of opponents remains limited.
Some fleeting passages can be frustrating.
reviewed at 25/09/2026 - [read the full review on GamesWelt]
-
FactorNews.com
-
The Pixel Post

Silent Hill Townfall Users & Customers reviews

(affiliate links)

amazon.com

check availability
instant-gaming

check availability

Info and Conclusion


Silent Hill Townfall review : Silent Hill Townfall seems to be very good in the category of Video Games, the reviews are very positive overall for this product and the "Pros" are higher than "Cons".

What rating did Silent Hill Townfall get?

An average rating of 4/5 with 46 ratings.

What price ?

(Check the price: amazon)
Ratings Silent Hill Townfall

Reviews of others Video Games Silent Hill

Test Silent Hill f, Test Silent Hill 2 Remake, Test Silent Hill The Short Message,
... and find all reviews find for brand Silent Hill

Your review and rating for Silent Hill Townfall: