4.1
5
40 ratings
Sonic x Shadow Generations Review: 45 Ratings, Pros and Cons
Date: (Last saved review: ) - Review: CommentChoisir.fr
Check all the 45 reviews find on Video Games Sonic x Shadow Generations, with the 40 ratings, comments, pros & cons from the reviewers.
Theses reviews and tests from Video Games magazines and websites give 40 ratings, we get this average rating to this Sonic product : 4.1/5.
Sonic x Shadow Generations review : With an average rating of 4.1/5, you can buy Sonic x Shadow Generations with your eyes closed (or almost). The opinions of the testers seem unanimous !
Sonic x Shadow Generations ratings
40 Ratings ranked from best to worst, green to good grades, red to bad,
Average rating: 4.1/5.
Source: https://www.commentChoisir.fr
| 9/10 Movies Games and Tech | 9/10 Checkpoint Gaming | 9/10 Nintendo Life | 90/100 MeuPlayStation |
| 9/10 Xbox Tavern | 9/10 MKAU Gaming | 9/10 tuttoteK | 90/100 Complete Xbox |
| 8.7/10 Vandal | 8.67/10 HeartBits VG | 86/100 Games.ch | 8.5/10 Well Played |
| 8.5/10 Pizza Fria | 17/20 GamerGen | 8.5/10 Beyond Gaming | 8.5/10 Comunidad Xbox |
| 8.5/10 HardwareZone | 8.2/10 LevelUp | 8.1/10 VideoChums | 4/5 GodIsAGeek |
| 8/10 GameReactor | 8/10 TheSixthAxis | 8/10 Shacknews | 8/10 GamingBolt |
| 8/10 Push Square | 8/10 Multiplayer.it | 80/100 COGconnected | 8/10 Niche Gamer |
| 80/100 NextN | 8/10 Nintendo World Report | 8/10 Geeky | 3.9/5 GamesCreed |
| 7.8/10 XBoxEra | 7.7/10 Areajugones | 7.5/10 Nintendo-Town | 7/10 Press Start |
| 7/10 PCGames | 7/10 GameKult.com | 3/5 EuroGamer.fr | 3/5 TheXboxHub |
5 Preview or review without rating: TierraGamer, DigitalTrends, Lords of Gaming, GamesWelt, TestingBuddies
For Video Games, ratings are sometimes different depending on the platform. Please refer to the good review...
Pros and cons for Sonic x Shadow Generations List of reviews and ratings
To better compare, we looked for you the advantages and disadvantages of Below and the notes given by specialized sites.
9
10
Movies Games and Tech
Great bundle with two fantastic sonic games.
Perfect remaster of Sonic generations already worth your time.
Shadow generations is a great way to deep dive into Shadows history.
Both games are great and different enough to not get stale or boring between the two games.
Perfect remaster of Sonic generations already worth your time.
Shadow generations is a great way to deep dive into Shadows history.
Both games are great and different enough to not get stale or boring between the two games.
reviewed at 21/10/2024 - [read the full review on Movies Games and Tech]
9
10
Checkpoint Gaming
Sonic Generations still holds up 13 years later
Shadow Generations perfects the Generations-style level design
Shadow's White Space hub world takes Frontiers' exploration and makes it better
All the lore, references, and fan moments a Shadow fan could ever need
Shadow Generations perfects the Generations-style level design
Shadow's White Space hub world takes Frontiers' exploration and makes it better
All the lore, references, and fan moments a Shadow fan could ever need
Boosts and loops result in occasional jank and glitches
reviewed at 21/10/2024 - [read the full review on Checkpoint Gaming]
9
10
Nintendo Life
Sonic Generations remains an excellent combination of 2D and 3D gameplay
New Shadow campaign is a true series highlight
Shadow's stages are some of the best we've ever seen
3D hub world is a delight to explore
Lots of cool pieces of music and artwork to unlock
Altered camera for Shadow Generations gives an improved view of the world
New Shadow campaign is a true series highlight
Shadow's stages are some of the best we've ever seen
3D hub world is a delight to explore
Lots of cool pieces of music and artwork to unlock
Altered camera for Shadow Generations gives an improved view of the world
A few challenge levels can be frustrating
Still no Chao Garden
Still no Chao Garden
reviewed at 28/10/2024 - [read the full review on Nintendo Life]
90
100
MeuPlayStation
Remastering removes Sonic Generations from limbo.
The remastering takes Sonic Generations out of limbo.
Extremely fun game
Impeccable soundtrack
The Shadow Generations double the playing time of the title.
An incredible level design
Open Zone returns in Shadow Generations
New collectible items in Sonic Generations
The Doom powers add even more fun to Shadow Generations.
Exciting and fun chefs
The remastering takes Sonic Generations out of limbo.
Extremely fun game
Impeccable soundtrack
The Shadow Generations double the playing time of the title.
An incredible level design
Open Zone returns in Shadow Generations
New collectible items in Sonic Generations
The Doom powers add even more fun to Shadow Generations.
Exciting and fun chefs
The camera can be obstructive at times.
The generations of shadows do not have many phases.
The generations of shadows do not have many phases.
reviewed at 30/10/2024 - [read the full review on MeuPlayStation]
9
10
Xbox Tavern
Basically two games (one is a remaster of a known great game!)
Shadow's campaign is excellent
Maybe one of the best pieces of 3D Sonic gameplay that exists as of today
Shadow's campaign is excellent
Maybe one of the best pieces of 3D Sonic gameplay that exists as of today
I wish it was a little longer
The variety of challenges feels a little low
The variety of challenges feels a little low
reviewed at 30/10/2024 - [read the full review on Xbox Tavern]
9
10
MKAU Gaming
2 epic Sonic games packed into one
The long overdue game that Shadow fans have been screaming for
Fast, furious, and adrenaline pumping with boss battles of epic proportions
Full of nostalgia
Ian Flynn?s writing fleshes out Shadow?s story
The long overdue game that Shadow fans have been screaming for
Fast, furious, and adrenaline pumping with boss battles of epic proportions
Full of nostalgia
Ian Flynn?s writing fleshes out Shadow?s story
Sonic Generations story isn?t as impactful
No zoom feature when looking at art
No zoom feature when looking at art
reviewed at 31/10/2024 - [read the full review on MKAU Gaming]
9
10
tuttoteK
No "Pros & Cons" find for this reviewer.
reviewed at 06/11/2024 - [read the full review on tuttoteK]
90
100
Complete Xbox
Shadow?s adventure
Shadow?s Doom Power
Faithful Sonic Generations remaster
Shadow?s Doom Power
Faithful Sonic Generations remaster
Length of Shadow?s adventure
reviewed at 15/11/2024 - [read the full review on Complete Xbox]
8.7
10
Vandal
No "Pros & Cons" find for this reviewer.
reviewed at 21/10/2024 - [read the full review on Vandal]
8.67
10
HeartBits VG
Good Shadow campaign
Enough additions to the original campaign
Interesting extras
Enough additions to the original campaign
Interesting extras
Game duration
reviewed at 12/11/2024 - [read the full review on HeartBits VG]
86
100
Games.ch
No "Pros & Cons" find for this reviewer.
reviewed at 21/10/2024 - [read the full review on Games.ch]
8.5
10
Well Played
High speed eye candy returns
Shadow?s unique gameplay is no mere palette swap
Sonic Generations is all here baby
Awesome extras to uncover and enjoy
Tons of replayability
Shadow?s unique gameplay is no mere palette swap
Sonic Generations is all here baby
Awesome extras to uncover and enjoy
Tons of replayability
The less fun parts of OG Generations are exactly as they were
No Chao Garden? C?mon man
No Chao Garden? C?mon man
reviewed at 21/10/2024 - [read the full review on Well Played]
8.5
10
Pizza Fria
Subtitled in Brazilian Portuguese
Online mode to increase the longevity of the game
The new campaign is extremely fun.
Online mode to increase the longevity of the game
The new campaign is extremely fun.
The camera may hinder your exploration.
The Mega Drive, which gave access to the entire original Sonic 1 campaign, has been removed.
The Mega Drive, which gave access to the entire original Sonic 1 campaign, has been removed.
reviewed at 21/10/2024 - [read the full review on Pizza Fria]
17
20
GamerGen
No "Pros & Cons" find for this reviewer.
reviewed at 01/01/1970 - [read the full review on GamerGen]
8.5
10
Beyond Gaming
Two games in one small package
Sonic Generations remains solid.
The Shadow generations are the best from Sonic Team in years.
Sonic Generations remains solid.
The Shadow generations are the best from Sonic Team in years.
The remastering of Sonic Generations is quite superficial.
reviewed at 04/11/2024 - [read the full review on Beyond Gaming]
8.5
10
Comunidad Xbox
No "Pros & Cons" find for this reviewer.
reviewed at 07/11/2024 - [read the full review on Comunidad Xbox]
8.5
10
HardwareZone
Shadow Generations alone is worth the price of the game
Fun gameplay elements
The remastering of Sonic Generations was done faithfully
Fantastic replayability that can seriously test your skills
Fun gameplay elements
The remastering of Sonic Generations was done faithfully
Fantastic replayability that can seriously test your skills
No new gameplay update to Sonic Generations
Some challenges are oddly boring
Some challenges are oddly boring
reviewed at 21/11/2024 - [read the full review on HardwareZone]
8.2
10
LevelUp
Sonic Generations benefits from visual improvements and the addition of the Drop Dash and Chaos research.
The white space like Overworld is extremely fun and full of things to do.
The Shadow levels in 2D and 3D are extraordinary.
Scenario design is used to exploit all the mechanics of Shadow.
Doom powers are very satisfying and fun movements to perform.
The new story of Shadow and its development seem more natural than those we saw in 2005.
The white space like Overworld is extremely fun and full of things to do.
The Shadow levels in 2D and 3D are extraordinary.
Scenario design is used to exploit all the mechanics of Shadow.
Doom powers are very satisfying and fun movements to perform.
The new story of Shadow and its development seem more natural than those we saw in 2005.
The duration of Sonic X Shadow Generations is very short, and depends on its replayability to feel that the purchase was worth it.
In the levels of Shadow, there are missing collectible items to motivate replayability.
Lack of variety in challenges
In the levels of Shadow, there are missing collectible items to motivate replayability.
Lack of variety in challenges
reviewed at 21/10/2024 - [read the full review on LevelUp]
8.1
10
VideoChums
Superb Sonic gameplay across many thrilling stages and challenges
Shadow's campaign is a great addition
Colourful presentation really pops
Shadow's campaign is a great addition
Colourful presentation really pops
Gameplay can be finicky at parts
Gated progression is kind of annoying
Some visuals could use fine-tuning
Gated progression is kind of annoying
Some visuals could use fine-tuning
reviewed at 21/10/2024 - [read the full review on VideoChums]
4
5
GodIsAGeek
A wonderful nostalgia trip through hedgehog history
Shadow has a great array of abilities
The open world hub is a joy to explore
Has content to keep you busy for weeks
Shadow has a great array of abilities
The open world hub is a joy to explore
Has content to keep you busy for weeks
Sonic Generations feels a touch dated
Shadow's stages are based on less memorable games
The White Space is a bit bland
Not all collectibles are exciting to obtain
Shadow's stages are based on less memorable games
The White Space is a bit bland
Not all collectibles are exciting to obtain
reviewed at 21/10/2024 - [read the full review on GodIsAGeek]
8
10
GameReactor
Generally cool levels throughout. Solid soundtrack. No lack of content. Good use of colour.
Controls still need refinement. The story doesn't really hit the mark. Shadow has a few too many abilities.
reviewed at 21/10/2024 - [read the full review on GameReactor]
8
10
TheSixthAxis
Great remaster
Even better new game
More options means more variety
Even better new game
More options means more variety
Quite short
Challenges may put some players off
Surfer dude Sonic is pretty lame
Challenges may put some players off
Surfer dude Sonic is pretty lame
reviewed at 21/10/2024 - [read the full review on TheSixthAxis]
8
10
Shacknews
This game says "Shadow the Hedgehog is the coolest and best" with its whole chest
Shadow Generations is some of the best 3D Sonic action to date
The soundtrack whips on both sides
Shadow Generations is some of the best 3D Sonic action to date
The soundtrack whips on both sides
Sonic Generations' flaws stand out more standing next to Shadow Generations' high quality
2D Sonic especially drops the ball
Fumbly learning curve for Shadow's full toolset
2D Sonic especially drops the ball
Fumbly learning curve for Shadow's full toolset
reviewed at 01/01/1970 - [read the full review on Shacknews]
8
10
GamingBolt
Sonic Generations has retained much of its strengths, especially in terms of 3D levels and level design in general
Shadow Generations boasts excellent levels, including a great new hub location
Shadow Generations feels excellent to play
Looks and runs great.
Shadow Generations boasts excellent levels, including a great new hub location
Shadow Generations feels excellent to play
Looks and runs great.
Sonic Generations' 2D levels are let down at times by frustrating movement-related issues
Sonic Generations' remaster is a pretty conservative upgrade.
Sonic Generations' remaster is a pretty conservative upgrade.
reviewed at 21/10/2024 - [read the full review on GamingBolt]
8
10
Push Square
Two games in one
Sonic Generations saved from PS3 hell
Shadow Generations is great
Shadow's varied gameplay
Shadow's improved level design
Sonic Generations saved from PS3 hell
Shadow Generations is great
Shadow's varied gameplay
Shadow's improved level design
Sonic Generations shows its age
Some iffy gameplay in Sonic
Some iffy gameplay in Sonic
reviewed at 21/10/2024 - [read the full review on Push Square]
8
10
Multiplayer.it
I am sharing a significantly improved technical graphic.
Parallel campaign dedicated to Shadow
Very rich in content
Parallel campaign dedicated to Shadow
Very rich in content
The Shadow mode suffers from some slowdowns.
Not all gameplay innovations are equally valid.
Slightly repetitive secondary challenges
Not all gameplay innovations are equally valid.
Slightly repetitive secondary challenges
reviewed at 21/10/2024 - [read the full review on Multiplayer.it]
80
100
COGconnected
Tons of new content
Shadow?s powers are rad
Sonic sections look crisp
Shadow?s powers are rad
Sonic sections look crisp
Sonic section mostly unchanged
Shadow powers a bit hobbled
Story is pretty basic
Shadow powers a bit hobbled
Story is pretty basic
reviewed at 21/10/2024 - [read the full review on COGconnected]
8
10
Niche Gamer
Both Sonics and Shadow control distinctly and have their own moves and quirks
The 3D "Boost" style stages and 2D stages are dense with alternate routes and collectibles that add substantial replay value
Shadow's Sonic Frontiers-inspired, fully 3D White Space hub area is fun as hell to explore
Endearing and rediculous shonen-style edgy melodrama that never fails to entertain
Good pinball minigame
The 3D "Boost" style stages and 2D stages are dense with alternate routes and collectibles that add substantial replay value
Shadow's Sonic Frontiers-inspired, fully 3D White Space hub area is fun as hell to explore
Endearing and rediculous shonen-style edgy melodrama that never fails to entertain
Good pinball minigame
Questionable changes cut gags from the original that make no sense
The game frequently goes autopilot during gameplay
If you don't follow Sonic lore, expect to be very confused at first
You can't go fishing with Big the Cat
The game frequently goes autopilot during gameplay
If you don't follow Sonic lore, expect to be very confused at first
You can't go fishing with Big the Cat
reviewed at 30/10/2024 - [read the full review on Niche Gamer]
80
100
NextN
No "Pros & Cons" find for this reviewer.
reviewed at 01/11/2024 - [read the full review on NextN]
8
10
Nintendo World Report
I love Shadow and this game does too
Speedrunning levels in Sonic Generations will never get old
This might be the most polished a new 3D Sonic game has ever been
Speedrunning levels in Sonic Generations will never get old
This might be the most polished a new 3D Sonic game has ever been
Shadow?s half of the game is held back by its ties to Sonic?s half
Sonic?s half of the game feels obviously dated compared to Shadow?s half
Sonic?s half of the game feels obviously dated compared to Shadow?s half
reviewed at 03/11/2024 - [read the full review on Nintendo World Report]
8
10
Geeky
No "Pros & Cons" find for this reviewer.
reviewed at 04/11/2024 - [read the full review on Geeky]
3.9
5
GamesCreed
New levels with refined mechanics and powers, making Shadow a standout character with a unique, thrilling playstyle.
Blends classic side-scrolling action with modern 3D platforming.
Offers updated graphics with the beloved gameplay of the original.
Shadow?s rock-heavy soundtrack adds to the intense experience.
Blends classic side-scrolling action with modern 3D platforming.
Offers updated graphics with the beloved gameplay of the original.
Shadow?s rock-heavy soundtrack adds to the intense experience.
Compared to Shadow?s polished levels, Sonic?s parts suffer from tricky targeting, frustrating enemy placements, and occasional awkward camera issues.
The story conclusion feels underwhelming and repetitive, lacking impact.
The story conclusion feels underwhelming and repetitive, lacking impact.
reviewed at 28/10/2024 - [read the full review on GamesCreed]
7.8
10
XBoxEra
Sonic Generations is pretty fun!
Shadow's character controller plays great and is very responsive.
Some great 3D stages with fun boss fights.
A nice little recap episode for Shadow the Hedgehog.
Shadow's character controller plays great and is very responsive.
Some great 3D stages with fun boss fights.
A nice little recap episode for Shadow the Hedgehog.
Sonic Generations is a barebones port with added bugs, a lack of polish, and no improvements.
Shadow's hub world is boring and scatterbrained. Challenge levels are nothing more than padding.
A fair bit of mechanic bloat on Shadow's part.
2D Shadow levels should be outlawed.
Shadow's hub world is boring and scatterbrained. Challenge levels are nothing more than padding.
A fair bit of mechanic bloat on Shadow's part.
2D Shadow levels should be outlawed.
reviewed at 03/11/2024 - [read the full review on XBoxEra]
7.7
10
Areajugones
Shadow campaign with new skills
Time travel is original.
Mix of 3D and 2D phases, twisted by the influence of Black Doom
The White Space brings something different.
Spanish dubbing
A large amount of collectibles and additional content
Time travel is original.
Mix of 3D and 2D phases, twisted by the influence of Black Doom
The White Space brings something different.
Spanish dubbing
A large amount of collectibles and additional content
The control of Shadow in certain phases is awkward.
Some repetitiveness in the levels of Shadow
The remastering does not bring many new features.
Some repetitiveness in the levels of Shadow
The remastering does not bring many new features.
reviewed at 21/10/2024 - [read the full review on Areajugones]
7.5
10
Nintendo-Town
Sonic Generations était un bon jeu, il l?est toujours
La bande-son au top
Le gros DLC Shadow apporte un gameplay intéressant
La bande-son au top
Le gros DLC Shadow apporte un gameplay intéressant
Hors la partie Shadow, on attendait plus de bonus pour un remaster
Toujours un peu court si on n?est pas amateurs de collectibles
Un jeu Xbox 360 ne devrait pas tourner aussi difficilement sur Nintendo Switch
Un DLC pour avoir du contenu en plus, sur un remaster, ça coince
Toujours un peu court si on n?est pas amateurs de collectibles
Un jeu Xbox 360 ne devrait pas tourner aussi difficilement sur Nintendo Switch
Un DLC pour avoir du contenu en plus, sur un remaster, ça coince
reviewed at 04/11/2024 - [read the full review on Nintendo-Town]
7
10
Press Start
Sonic Generations blends classic and modern in a fun adventure
Revisiting history of the franchise through classic stages and themes
Colours pop and graphics are sharp
Revisiting history of the franchise through classic stages and themes
Colours pop and graphics are sharp
No mid-point between controlling Shadow - either too floaty or too sensitive
Sense of speed can be overwhelming, even for a Sonic/Shadow game
Having to quit to the main menu to switch games
Shadow Generations feels almost like an afterthought
Sense of speed can be overwhelming, even for a Sonic/Shadow game
Having to quit to the main menu to switch games
Shadow Generations feels almost like an afterthought
reviewed at 21/10/2024 - [read the full review on Press Start]
7
10
PCGames
No "Pros & Cons" find for this reviewer.
reviewed at 25/10/2024 - [read the full review on PCGames]
7
10
GameKult.com
No "Pros & Cons" find for this reviewer.
reviewed at 30/10/2024 - [read the full review on GameKult.com]
3
5
EuroGamer.fr
No "Pros & Cons" find for this reviewer.
reviewed at 21/10/2024 - [read the full review on EuroGamer.fr]
3
5
TheXboxHub
Brand-new campaign thrown in
Shadow?s White Space is full of things to find
Shadow?s White Space is full of things to find
Same issues persist
Even classic Sonic feels awkward to control
Even classic Sonic feels awkward to control
reviewed at 05/11/2024 - [read the full review on TheXboxHub]
-
not scored
TierraGamerNo "Pros & Cons" find for this reviewer.
reviewed at 21/10/2024 - [read the full review on TierraGamer]
-
not scored
DigitalTrendsSmooth Sonic remaster
Shadow Generations is fantastic
Excellent music
Lots of collectibles
Shadow Generations is fantastic
Excellent music
Lots of collectibles
Sonic Generations movement can be rough
So can its late levels
So can its bosses
So can its late levels
So can its bosses
reviewed at 25/10/2024 - [read the full review on DigitalTrends]
-
not scored
Lords of GamingNo "Pros & Cons" find for this reviewer.
reviewed at 26/10/2024 - [read the full review on Lords of Gaming]
-
not scored
GamesWeltAn adrenaline-filled tribute to the best episodes of Sonic
excellent gameplay
A more beautiful minimal lighting, higher resolution, and a solid 60 FPS.
two selectable graphic modes
Soundtrack partly loaded with culture
Good additional content in the Shadow game mode
a collection of souvenirs for true Sonic fans
excellent gameplay
A more beautiful minimal lighting, higher resolution, and a solid 60 FPS.
two selectable graphic modes
Soundtrack partly loaded with culture
Good additional content in the Shadow game mode
a collection of souvenirs for true Sonic fans
graphically a bit outdated
The shadow mode feels artificially stretched.
more pop-ins (rare) - especially during games projected on the facades of houses
The shadow mode feels artificially stretched.
more pop-ins (rare) - especially during games projected on the facades of houses
reviewed at 30/10/2024 - [read the full review on GamesWelt]
-
not scored
TestingBuddiesNo "Pros & Cons" find for this reviewer.
reviewed at 12/11/2024 - [read the full review on TestingBuddies]
Reviews of youtubers
We find these video-Reviews & tests on youtube about Sonic x Shadow Generations
Videos Tests Sonic x Shadow Generations
Reviews of others Video Games Sonic
Test Sonic Superstars, Test Sonic Origins Plus, Test Sonic Origins,... and find all reviews find for brand Sonic
Info and ConclusionSonic x Shadow Generations
What rating did Sonic x Shadow Generations get?
An average rating of 4.1/5 with 40 ratings.What price ?
Your review and rating for Sonic x Shadow Generations:
Did you buy or tested this product ?
