Check all the 66 reviews find on Video Games A Plague Tale Legacy, with the 49 ratings, comments, pros & cons from the reviewers.
Theses reviews and tests from Video Games magazines and websites give 49 ratings, we get this average rating to this A Plague Tale product : 3.9/5.
En bref
- 66 reviews and opinions with 49 ratings for A Plague Tale Legacy
- We obtain an average score of 3.9/5, or 78.37/100
- NDA on Reviews ? Please note that 45 reviews were published the same day 26/08/2026.
A Plague Tale Legacy ratings
Source: https://www.commentChoisir.fr
| 5/5 Geeks By Girls | 95/100 Complete Xbox | 92/100 XBoxOrNot |
| 9/10 GameBlog.fr | 9/10 GameSpew | 9/10 TheSixthAxis |
| 9/10 ZTGD | 9/10 GamersGlobal | 9/10 Pizza Fria |
| 9/10 Xbox-Mag | 90/100 Windows Central | 88/100 Games.ch |
| 88/100 Generación Xbox | 86/100 Console Tribe | 85/100 Gaming Trend |
| 85/100 COGconnected | 4/5 GamesRadar | 8/10 GameReactor |
| 8/10 Shacknews | 8/10 GameInformer | 4/5 TheXboxHub |
| 8/10 Areajugones | 8/10 Hinsusta | 8/10 Multiplayer.it |
| 8/10 Beyond Gaming | 8/10 XBoxEra | 8/10 Press Start |
| 8/10 GameScore.it | 8/10 Comunidad Xbox | 8/10 BagoGames |
| 8/10 GameSpace | 8/10 NerdMovieProductions | 76/100 PCGamer |
| 15/20 GamerGen | 7/10 GameKult.com | 7/10 Journal du Geek |
| 7/10 ActuGaming | 7/10 wccftech | 70/100 JVFrance |
| 7/10 Numerama | 7/10 MeriStation | 3/5 EuroGamer.fr |
| 6/10 Try a Game | 6/10 IGN | 3/5 NME |
| 6/10 GameHope | 3/5 PXLBBQ |
For Video Games, ratings are sometimes different depending on the platform. Please refer to the good review...
Pros and cons for A Plague Tale Legacy List of reviews and ratings
To better compare, we looked for you the advantages and disadvantages of Below and the notes given by specialized sites.


The myth of the Minotaur and its integration in A Plague Tale
The five levels of difficulty
The significant number of parameters
A lifespan between 10 and 15 hours
A license that has been able to renew itself
The creature
Sophia and Leni, a charming duo
the entirety of the technical aspect and artistic direction
Riddles that may seem too easy and appear to be mostly there to prolong the game's lifespan.


The audio is out of this world
Exceptional cinematic
Smooth controls
The dual timeline is a novel twist
Loads of replay value
A brilliant addition to the franchise


Exceptional artistic direction
Dynamic and efficient fights
Well-crafted riddles
Masterful soundtrack
Successful narration around Sophia
The French dubbing
Sometimes we feel that AI is patiently waiting its turn before trying to kill us.


Enjoyable puzzles
Engaging story
Impressive visuals


Exploring the Minotaur's island is great
A very distinctive monster lurking in the dark
Great soundtrack adds to the atmosphere
I was expecting a bit more from the final confrontation


Combat is fun
Perfectly paced
Stellar story and characters
Minor frame drops


In the game's internal notebook, all information about the puzzles is automatically saved.
Fair checkpoint system from all points of view
Agile sword combat system
Designing engaging puzzles (clues mainly provided upon request rather than unsolicited)
Exciting and thrilling escape sequences.
An exciting setting and a likeable heroine
Elaborate staging
Decent playtime (around 15 hours)
Elegant graphics with mainly good effects (lighting).
Mainly very good animations
No visible loading time (except in case of death on screen)
An exceptional atmospheric soundtrack
Good fully localized German version
Excellent sound effects
Some sections appear slightly stretched.
Small weaknesses in small details such as hair


Exceptional graphic presentation
Soundtrack among the great strengths
Good variety between combat, exploration, puzzles, and stealth.
The story is gaining momentum and justifies Sophia's choice.
Some mechanics follow well-known paths from other action and adventure games.
The narration takes some time to show the real importance of this story for A Plague Tale.


Exceptional atmosphere
Gameplay in intense combat
Smart and well-integrated riddles
Fascinating mythological part
Presence of a chapter selector
Some unnatural animations


Responsive, polished combat
Beautifully realized dual worlds
Some simplistic puzzle design


Floating-arm combat system
Successful and varied puzzle design
A generally appealing mix of gameplay including combat, puzzles, platforming, and exploration options (albeit smaller).
Good fully localized German version
Elegant and technically very clean design
Reasonable solo playtime (approximately 15 hours)
[88/100] reviewed at 26/08/2026 - Test Resonance: A Plague Tale Legacy - Test / [read the full review on Games.ch]


The soundtrack must win an award this year.
The approach to combat seems very good to me.
I would have loved for them to include a Latin Spanish dub.


Designing environmental puzzles (literally) brilliant!
The change of gender has definitely been successful...
A few small technical uncertainties
Mediocre longevity


Beautiful environments accompanied by an outstanding soundtrack
Well-balanced gameplay that combines action, exploration, puzzles, and story
Works as standalone entry for newcomers to the series


Excellent puzzles
Interesting narrative
Enjoyable combat
Strong characters
Combat?s a little clunky
Explore-puzzle-combat cycle gets predictable


Great story that's both standalone and additive to Plague Tale
+
Swordplay is simple but rewards momentum
+
Puzzles vary enough to remain engaging throughout
Combat areas could be more varied
-
More could have been made of the grapple
-
Now I have to wait for the next one


A gripping story
A good balance between combat, stealth, puzzles and exploration
These bugs aren't insurmountable, but they are annoying


Beautiful world
Clever puzzles
Stealth segments feel tense and genuinely scary
Segments start to feel samey toward the end
Skill tree doesn't add much


Puzzles are engaging
Great story
Amazing visuals
Brilliant voice cast and score


Exploration and very fun puzzles
Dynamic and fun combat
The story is below Innocence and Requiem.
The path to action causes the saga to lose part of its identity.


Varied game
Fantastic setting
Frequent frame rate drops


The new action gameplay works.
A wonderful story and very well told.
A particular aspect of the plot did not convince us.
Navigating through scenarios can often lead to dead times.


Sophia is a convincing new leader.
The mythological approach works perfectly.
Puzzles bring variety.
Do not expect a focus on stealth like in previous games.
No rats in sight


Excellent OST
Good mix of puzzles and platforming
Competent combat


Simple but strong combat system
Novel take on some classic mythology
Inconsistent puzzle quality


Good variety between battles, exploration, and puzzles.
Sophia works well as the protagonist, and is highlighted by an interesting story.
Progression, skills, and equipment have less impact than they could have.
Some light-based puzzles are repetitive.


Good adventure and action game
Organic and intuitive puzzles
Artistic design and Minoan ambiance
There are people who will regret the other approach.


Great combat system
Some great narrative moments
Underutilized narrative potential


Vivid characters
New combat system
Combat and research complement one another
Outstanding graphics
Fantastic OST: A real soundtrack of the year contender
Not much variety in puzzles
Occasional choppy combat animations
Too few locations


Captivating and full of twists and turns history
Well-structured and increasingly elaborate riddles.
High-level technical department
An interesting alternation between battles, exploration, puzzles, and escapes.
Progression and rewards of exploration are not very significant.
Some riddles tend to repeat themselves.




The best OST of the franchise, by far.
Sophia turns out to be much more complex than expected (and that's a good thing)
The quality of writing, which has gained some recognition
Thank you for not imposing a mandatory backseat on us.
The weak combat system
It was really not worth bothering with this pseudo RPG overlay.


The labyrinthine and freely explorable level design
Sophia, what a queen
The staging of the narration
Generic themes
Uneven gameplay quality


Flawless soundtrack as always
Riddles thoughtfully designed for everyone
Flowered accessibility settings
Narrative elements that make sense with the first two titles
Uneven character development
Slow start to the scenario
Chapter arrangement sometimes poorly thought out


Compelling exploration and platforming
Gripping later-game horror sections
Visuals are often stunning
Nice soundtrack
Combat is bland and frustrating
Campaign feels overstuffed


Effective gameplay in its approach
A pleasant overall atmosphere from start to finish
French dubbing and high-quality original soundtracks
Many accessibility options to cater to all audiences
Too short in a straight line (about 12 hours) with limited replayability.
Interesting but predictable story
A fairly repetitive gameplay loop (exploration/combat/infiltration...)
A corridor game that lacks large areas to explore.
Still a few bugs (before the day one patch)


Sophia is a pleasant character to play (and who avoids speaking unnecessarily)
A very effective mix of influences (Uncharted, Assassin's Creed, Resident Evil)
Writing the scenario AND the NPCs is really not incredible.
For the originality of the overall proposal, we'll have to pass.


Visually, it's a delight. The sets are beautiful and graphically very powerful.
This works very well as a prequel to A Plague Tale: Innocence and Requiem. Sofia is a great protagonist.
Some situations repeat themselves too often. The passing of hours makes things predictable.
The pace slows down in sections with more action. There are areas with too many enemies that drag on for too long and become monotonous.


The soundtrack of Olivier Deriviere
The ending copied from Requiem
Less deep, less engaging
Basic level design


Surprisingly great combat sequences
The narrative intrigues throughout, telling a unique story
The ambitious tale?s emotional climax fails to fully land
Where?s the minotaur?!


A great French dubbing
Inventive riddles...
We still enjoy making progress.
The light-RPG layer is not essential.
... but sometimes too repetitive
Never deviate from its structure of exploration/puzzles/combat.
Quite generic in the end
[6/10] reviewed at 07/09/2026 - Resonance : A Plague Tale Legacy (PS5) [read the full review on GameHope]
[6/10] reviewed at 07/09/2026 - Resonance : A Plague Tale Legacy (PC) [read the full review on GameHope]
Grandiose staging
Harmonious soundtrack
Exciting setting
An underdeveloped combat system that doesn't play as cool as it looks.
poorly explained riddles
Chaotic rhythm
+ An engaging story with twists and turns, which has connections with the A Plague Tale duology.
A light but effective combat system
+ A truly sublime artistic direction
+ A soundtrack that delights the ears
+ A correct and sufficient lifespan
A good variety in the bestiary and the multiple dangers
Not too easy, not too difficult riddles.
Small discrepancies in lip synchronization
Sophia and Leni, a duo less strong than Amicia and Hugo from Rune.
An adventure slightly less emotional than its predecessor.
Fast combat system with a focus on parrying.
Cryptic puzzle in the style of Uncharted and Tomb Raider
High quality graphics
Pompous music
a successful musical adaptation in German
15 hours of competent entertainment
The story progresses a bit aimlessly.
Boss fights are not a strong point.
More offensive combat
Successful combat system
Welcome back to the results.
Exciting puzzle passages
A lot of variety
Partially freely explorable environment
Elegant design
Great soundtrack
Good performance
Complete musical adaptation in German
Sometimes riddles can be quite boring and repetitive.
The combat system wears out a little over time.
Short playing time
Basic skills tree
Unique Combination Of Genres
Gorgeous Visuals
Superb Audio Design
Brilliant Soundtrack
Puzzles Are Stale And Too Similar
A Plague Tale Legacy Users & Customers reviews
(affiliate links)
Reviews of youtubers
We find these video-Reviews & tests on youtube about A Plague Tale Legacy
Videos Tests A Plague Tale LegacyInfo and Conclusion
A Plague Tale Legacy review : A Plague Tale Legacy seems to be very good in the category of Video Games, the reviews are very positive overall for this product and the "Pros" are higher than "Cons".
What rating did A Plague Tale Legacy get?
An average rating of 3.9/5 with 49 ratings.What price ?
(Check the price: amazon)
Reviews of others Video Games A Plague Tale
Test A Plague Tale Requiem, Test A Plague Tale Innocence,... and find all reviews find for brand A Plague Tale
Your review and rating for A Plague Tale Legacy:
[4.3/5] Star Wars Galactic Racer
[3.7/5] Hellraiser Revival
[4.1/5] Dragon's Dogma Dark Arisen
[3.7/5] Valor Mortis
[4.3/5] Gears of War E-Day