3.7
5
58 ratings
Check all the 78 reviews find on Video Games Mafia The Old Country, with the 58 ratings, comments, pros & cons from the reviewers.
Theses reviews and tests from Video Games magazines and websites give 58 ratings, we get this average rating to this Mafia product : 3.7/5.
En bref
- 78 reviews and opinions with 58 ratings for Mafia The Old Country
- We obtain an average score of 3.7/5, or 73.67/100
- Warning this product has been rated 1 times severely, with very low scores, read the tests associated with these ratings.
Mafia The Old Country ratings
58 Ratings ranked from best to worst, green to good grades, red to bad,
Average rating: 3.7/5.
Source: https://www.commentChoisir.fr
| 5/5 TechPowerUp | 9/10 Areajugones | 90/100 Generación Xbox |
| 9/10 MKAU Gaming | 85/100 COGconnected | 81/100 Games.ch |
| 8/10 PCGames | 8/10 wccftech | 8/10 GamersGlobal |
| 8/10 Checkpoint Gaming | 80/100 TierraGamer | 8/10 GamingBolt |
| 8/10 Vandal | 8/10 Journal du Geek | 8/10 GameOver |
| 8/10 Xbox-Mag | 4/5 TheXboxHub | 4/5 N-Gamz |
| 8/10 SuccesOne | 8/10 Geeky | 8/10 NerdMovieProductions |
| 8/10 Comunidad Xbox | 8/10 Coplanet | 8/10 ZTGD |
| 8/10 PixelCritics | 75/100 JVFrance | 15/20 GamerGen |
| 75/100 GamerClick | 72/100 Fortress Of Solitude | 7/10 GameKult.com |
| 7/10 Multiplayer.it | 7/10 Hinsusta | 7/10 Xbox Tavern |
| 7/10 Movies Games and Tech | 7/10 Numerama | 7/10 Pizza Fria |
| 70/100 Console Tribe | 70/100 Complete Xbox | 7/10 VideoChums |
| 7/10 GameHope | 14/20 JeuxActu.com | 7/10 tuttoteK |
| 6/10 DigitalTrends | 6/10 GameSpot | 6/10 GameReactor |
| 6/10 GameInformer | 6/10 Push Square | 3/5 EuroGamer.fr |
| 6/10 ActuGaming | 3/5 NME | 3/5 Geek Generation |
| 6/10 KeenGamer | 3/5 GamesCreed | 4/10 Well Played |
20 Preview or review without rating: hyNerd.it, Gaming Trend, GeekCulture, JeuxVideo.com, GamesWelt, Computer Bild, ComputerBase, Xboxygen, TestingBuddies, Game-eXperience.it, CowCotLand.com, Beyond Gaming, Smartworld, FactorNews.com, Tweakers, PlaySense, Future Zone, Beebom, Consollection, GeekiT
For Video Games, ratings are sometimes different depending on the platform. Please refer to the good review...
Pros and cons for Mafia The Old Country List of reviews and ratings
To better compare, we looked for you the advantages and disadvantages of Below and the notes given by specialized sites.
5
5
TechPowerUp
No "Pros & Cons" find at TechPowerUp
reviewed at 11/08/2025 - [read the full review on TechPowerUp]
8
10
PCGames
No "Pros & Cons" find at PCGames
[8/10] reviewed at 09/09/2024 - Mafia trifft auf Tatortreiniger: Das wahrscheinlich blutigste Spiel des Jahres [read the full review on PCGames]
[9/10] reviewed at 07/08/2025 - Mafia: The Old Country im Test - zwischen Messerduellen, Mafia-Ehre und emotionaler Story [read the full review on PCGames]
[9/10] reviewed at 07/08/2025 - Mafia: The Old Country im Test - zwischen Messerduellen, Mafia-Ehre und emotionaler Story [read the full review on PCGames]
9
10
Areajugones
Absolutely masterful Spanish dubbing
A cinematic narrative that moves you from the very first minute.
Enzo Favala as an authentically human protagonist
Graphs that constantly surprise
A cohesive experience from start to finish
Impeccable narrative pace without artificial filler
A cinematic narrative that moves you from the very first minute.
Enzo Favala as an authentically human protagonist
Graphs that constantly surprise
A cohesive experience from start to finish
Impeccable narrative pace without artificial filler
Vehicle management is something that needs improvement.
The shooting game could be slightly improved.
The shooting game could be slightly improved.
reviewed at 07/08/2025 - [read the full review on Areajugones]
90
100
Generación Xbox
Cinematic staging: carefully recreates Sicily in 1900 with attention to detail and remarkable artistic direction.
Captivating story: Enzo's descent into organized crime is told with strength and authenticity.
Reduced price, Spanish dubbing and without filling.
Captivating story: Enzo's descent into organized crime is told with strength and authenticity.
Reduced price, Spanish dubbing and without filling.
Marked linearity: although intentional, this can leave a feeling of lack of freedom or exploration between missions.
Irregular enemy AI: some enemies react clumsily in certain shootouts or remain exposed in an illogical manner.
Irregular enemy AI: some enemies react clumsily in certain shootouts or remain exposed in an illogical manner.
reviewed at 07/08/2025 - [read the full review on Generación Xbox]
9
10
MKAU Gaming
Beautiful, detailed, atmospheric graphics that capture the Sicilian setting perfectly
Immersive sound design with top-tier voice acting
Smooth, responsive controls that allow fluid movements
Strong, emotionally engaging narrative filled with themes of loyalty, power and sacrifice
Subtle environmental touches that bring the world to life
Immersive sound design with top-tier voice acting
Smooth, responsive controls that allow fluid movements
Strong, emotionally engaging narrative filled with themes of loyalty, power and sacrifice
Subtle environmental touches that bring the world to life
Occasional character model glitches, such as the bizarre stretching of field workers
Gun movement sometimes felt a little quick
Gun movement sometimes felt a little quick
reviewed at 11/08/2025 - [read the full review on MKAU Gaming]
85
100
COGconnected
Well-Paced Story
Overall Presentation
Focused, Linear Adventure
Overall Presentation
Focused, Linear Adventure
Formulaic Mission Structure
Open World is Pointless
A Little Repetitive
Open World is Pointless
A Little Repetitive
reviewed at 11/08/2025 - [read the full review on COGconnected]
81
100
Games.ch
A very well-crafted story, mainly of first-class quality.
Varied game and overall excellent pace
Atmospheric and vast gaming world
Atmospheric soundtrack and powerful sound effects
A very good quality of voice (also in German)
Despite some minor flaws, detailed and fabulous photorealistic graphics (PC)
Appropriate game length for a story-focused game (around 15 hours in "Normal" mode)
Varied game and overall excellent pace
Atmospheric and vast gaming world
Atmospheric soundtrack and powerful sound effects
A very good quality of voice (also in German)
Despite some minor flaws, detailed and fabulous photorealistic graphics (PC)
Appropriate game length for a story-focused game (around 15 hours in "Normal" mode)
Weak AI (especially in stealth mode)
Game design can sometimes be conservative or even outdated.
Game design can sometimes be conservative or even outdated.
reviewed at 07/08/2025 - [read the full review on Games.ch]
8
10
wccftech
Great visuals and authenticity
Excellent narrative and characters, though lacking major twists from the usual Mafia plot fare
Solid gameplay...
Excellent narrative and characters, though lacking major twists from the usual Mafia plot fare
Solid gameplay...
...that is however not as good as the genre's best
No real exploration or side activities
No real exploration or side activities
reviewed at 07/08/2025 - [read the full review on wccftech]
8
10
GamersGlobal
Good tutorial
Three selectable levels of difficulty
Reactive control with game controller
Possible chapter replays before the end of the story.
A very good mafia story...
Many things to collect and unlock in the world...
A good pace in the countryside
Well-written dialogues and cinematically staged intermediate sequences.
Cover shooting battles with a good dose of punch
Spectacular hunting/chase sequences
Stealth mechanics and knife combat increase the diversity of gameplay.
Very good graphics, often photorealistic with many details and a great draw distance (PC)
Actors digitized by motion capture and performance capture
Mainly first-class character animations with fine facial expressiveness.
Atmospheric and catchy original soundtrack, propelling the fight.
Rich and often realistic sound effects
Several language options available on board, including a good synchronization in German.
Three selectable levels of difficulty
Reactive control with game controller
Possible chapter replays before the end of the story.
A very good mafia story...
Many things to collect and unlock in the world...
A good pace in the countryside
Well-written dialogues and cinematically staged intermediate sequences.
Cover shooting battles with a good dose of punch
Spectacular hunting/chase sequences
Stealth mechanics and knife combat increase the diversity of gameplay.
Very good graphics, often photorealistic with many details and a great draw distance (PC)
Actors digitized by motion capture and performance capture
Mainly first-class character animations with fine facial expressiveness.
Atmospheric and catchy original soundtrack, propelling the fight.
Rich and often realistic sound effects
Several language options available on board, including a good synchronization in German.
... even if partly predictable
"Open world" is in itself just a simple (beautiful) backdrop.
Conservative game design up to outdated
KI in incompetent Stealth point
Many graphical bugs, but almost exclusively of small size.
The cutscenes also run on PC with a maximum of 30 frames per second.
The sound in the German version is a bit too loud.
"Open world" is in itself just a simple (beautiful) backdrop.
Conservative game design up to outdated
KI in incompetent Stealth point
Many graphical bugs, but almost exclusively of small size.
The cutscenes also run on PC with a maximum of 30 frames per second.
The sound in the German version is a bit too loud.
reviewed at 07/08/2025 - [read the full review on GamersGlobal]
8
10
Checkpoint Gaming
Stunning Sicilian worldbuilding
Deep, character-driven storytelling
Authentic voice acting and culture
Strong visual and art direction
Memorable missions and set-pieces
Deep, character-driven storytelling
Authentic voice acting and culture
Strong visual and art direction
Memorable missions and set-pieces
Basic combat and stealth
Underwritten women and predictable beats
Underwritten women and predictable beats
reviewed at 07/08/2025 - [read the full review on Checkpoint Gaming]
80
100
TierraGamer
No "Pros & Cons" find at TierraGamer
reviewed at 07/08/2025 - [read the full review on TierraGamer]
8
10
GamingBolt
Great storytelling, Excellent character development, Strong voice acting and production values, Solid set pieces, Combat and stealth mechanics are simple but effective
Abrupt transition in story towards the end, Limited Replay Value
reviewed at 07/08/2025 - [read the full review on GamingBolt]
8
10
Vandal
The story is a great tribute to mafia cinema.
The fantastic and well-kept atmosphere of Sicily.
His direct and concise approach, a return to the roots of the saga.
The fantastic and well-kept atmosphere of Sicily.
His direct and concise approach, a return to the roots of the saga.
A world that sometimes feels too limited.
The mechanics of discretion, simple and unambitious.
Some frame drops that tarnish the experience at certain specific moments.
The mechanics of discretion, simple and unambitious.
Some frame drops that tarnish the experience at certain specific moments.
reviewed at 08/08/2025 - [read the full review on Vandal]
8
10
Journal du Geek
The incredible atmosphere (universe, map, characters, context...)
Graphically, quite nice thanks to UE5
The abandonment of open-world in favor of a return to a very linear narrative solo experience.
The charisma, dubbing, and acting of the characters (main and secondary)
The very cool map that fits perfectly into the story
The gunfights, driving (in a car), and galloping (on horseback) are quite convincing.
12 hours of average lifespan for the scenario, simple, effective and to the point, we don't get bored and it doesn't drag on.
Graphically, quite nice thanks to UE5
The abandonment of open-world in favor of a return to a very linear narrative solo experience.
The charisma, dubbing, and acting of the characters (main and secondary)
The very cool map that fits perfectly into the story
The gunfights, driving (in a car), and galloping (on horseback) are quite convincing.
12 hours of average lifespan for the scenario, simple, effective and to the point, we don't get bored and it doesn't drag on.
A few minor technical issues (occasional frame rate drops, popping in certain cutscenes)
Gameplay still too rigid and too classic
The AI is lagging behind
The knife boss fights are very repetitive.
Gameplay still too rigid and too classic
The AI is lagging behind
The knife boss fights are very repetitive.
reviewed at 11/08/2025 - [read the full review on Journal du Geek]
8
10
GameOver
The magnificent representation of Sicily in 1900.
Mature and neat writing, with careful characters.
A duration of 10 to 12 hours is sufficient to provide a complete experience and avoid unnecessary "lulls".
Mature and neat writing, with careful characters.
A duration of 10 to 12 hours is sufficient to provide a complete experience and avoid unnecessary "lulls".
The slow pace can be tiring.
Stealth is outdated and the shooting is typical and simplistic.
Stealth is outdated and the shooting is typical and simplistic.
reviewed at 11/08/2025 - [read the full review on GameOver]
8
10
Xbox-Mag
Very successful atmosphere
Pleasant rural setting
Good pacing in the storyline
Impeccable sound quality
Technically very correct
Varied gameplay phases
Dubbing in French and Sicilian
Performance mode on point
Pleasant rural setting
Good pacing in the storyline
Impeccable sound quality
Technically very correct
Varied gameplay phases
Dubbing in French and Sicilian
Performance mode on point
Some very long loading times
Animations that lack naturalness
Map quite empty after all
Fairly predictable scenario
Animations that lack naturalness
Map quite empty after all
Fairly predictable scenario
reviewed at 12/08/2025 - [read the full review on Xbox-Mag]
4
5
TheXboxHub
Beautiful visuals
Great sound
Fun and thrilling driving
Exciting set pieces
Great sound
Fun and thrilling driving
Exciting set pieces
Needs a more open world
Too many knife fights
Too many knife fights
reviewed at 13/08/2025 - [read the full review on TheXboxHub]
4
5
N-Gamz
Charming characters like Isabella and Cesare.
Stunning and immersive set designs
An exploration mode to collect collectibles at your leisure
A compelling story about the rise to power of a "nobody"
Exciting gunfights
An affordable price of 50?
Some incredible music (although sometimes a bit too discreet)
A top-notch French dubbing
"Sicilian" dubbing integrated
A cinematic aspect that the saga had lost with Mafia 3.
A historical period and a geographical location rarely seen in a video game.
A world filled with details in every direction...
Stunning and immersive set designs
An exploration mode to collect collectibles at your leisure
A compelling story about the rise to power of a "nobody"
Exciting gunfights
An affordable price of 50?
Some incredible music (although sometimes a bit too discreet)
A top-notch French dubbing
"Sicilian" dubbing integrated
A cinematic aspect that the saga had lost with Mafia 3.
A historical period and a geographical location rarely seen in a video game.
A world filled with details in every direction...
... but unfortunately too little interactive
Frame rate drops even in smooth mode
Highly scripted racing phases
A not really rewarding exploration in the main missions
Simple and repetitive infiltration phases
Too few secondary activities
A little short (12h)
Frame rate drops even in smooth mode
Highly scripted racing phases
A not really rewarding exploration in the main missions
Simple and repetitive infiltration phases
Too few secondary activities
A little short (12h)
reviewed at 16/08/2025 - [read the full review on N-Gamz]
8
10
SuccesOne
Captivating narration
Authentic atmosphere
Variety of missions
Historical accuracy of weapons
Authentic atmosphere
Variety of missions
Historical accuracy of weapons
Gameplay too linear
Uncertain driving
Repetitive knife duels
Uneven modeling of NPCs
Uncertain driving
Repetitive knife duels
Uneven modeling of NPCs
reviewed at 19/08/2025 - [read the full review on SuccesOne]
8
10
Geeky
No "Pros & Cons" find at Geeky
reviewed at 19/08/2025 - [read the full review on Geeky]
8
10
NerdMovieProductions
Mature and polished writing, with well-defined characters.
Beautiful representation of Sicily in 1900.
Interesting and original knife management.
Unique soundtrack and dubbing...
Beautiful representation of Sicily in 1900.
Interesting and original knife management.
Unique soundtrack and dubbing...
Sometimes, the dubbing is too complex for non-Sicilians and the performance is not always perfect.
Some sporadic technical issues and some anachronistic details.
AI with low intelligence that makes infiltration obsolete and shooting unsatisfying.
Some sporadic technical issues and some anachronistic details.
AI with low intelligence that makes infiltration obsolete and shooting unsatisfying.
reviewed at 21/08/2025 - [read the full review on NerdMovieProductions]
8
10
Comunidad Xbox
Simple story, but told in a brilliant way.
Luxury decoration
Folded and translated into Spanish
Technically, he has some very beastly things...
Luxury decoration
Folded and translated into Spanish
Technically, he has some very beastly things...
... and others very simple and basic.
The gameplay eventually becomes repetitive.
The artificial intelligence of the enemies is quite poor.
The gameplay eventually becomes repetitive.
The artificial intelligence of the enemies is quite poor.
reviewed at 22/08/2025 - [read the full review on Comunidad Xbox]
8
10
Coplanet
Sicilian setting from 1900 recreated with care and realism.
Immersive story and memorable, well-characterized characters.
Professional dubbing entirely in Sicilian of excellent quality
Impressive technical sharing thanks to Unreal Engine 5
Narrative focus without filler or unnecessary content
Immersive story and memorable, well-characterized characters.
Professional dubbing entirely in Sicilian of excellent quality
Impressive technical sharing thanks to Unreal Engine 5
Narrative focus without filler or unnecessary content
Traditional and not very innovative game in combat.
Exploration outside of collectible items is not very rewarding.
Absence of any endgame content
Exploration outside of collectible items is not very rewarding.
Absence of any endgame content
reviewed at 26/08/2025 - [read the full review on Coplanet]
8
10
ZTGD
No "Pros & Cons" find at ZTGD
reviewed at 16/09/2025 - [read the full review on ZTGD]
6
10
KeenGamer
Beautiful Atmosphere
Intriguing Characters
Deep Story
Immersive Setting
Intriguing Characters
Deep Story
Immersive Setting
Extremely Linear
Repetitive Gameplay Loops
Knife Fights Get Old Fast
No Mini-Map, Exploration is Tedious
Ending Undermines the Player Effort
Gun and Vehicle Upgrades are Pointless
No Side Missions, Little Variety
Repetitive Gameplay Loops
Knife Fights Get Old Fast
No Mini-Map, Exploration is Tedious
Ending Undermines the Player Effort
Gun and Vehicle Upgrades are Pointless
No Side Missions, Little Variety
[6/10] reviewed at 09/10/2025 - Mafia: The Old Country Review ? A Game You Can?t Refuse (PC) [read the full review on KeenGamer]
[8/10] reviewed at 09/10/2025 - Mafia: The Old Country Review ? Strictly Loyal (PS5) [read the full review on KeenGamer]
[8/10] reviewed at 09/10/2025 - Mafia: The Old Country Review ? Strictly Loyal (PS5) [read the full review on KeenGamer]
8
10
PixelCritics
Absolutely dense and intoxicating atmosphere
Unprecedented and fascinating Sicilian setting around 1900.
Excellent script and excellent English actors.
Strict focus on the story without the clutter of an open world.
Phenomenal sound design, especially for vehicles.
Clean and robust technical experience on PC (UE5)
Clever connections with predecessors for fans.
Unprecedented and fascinating Sicilian setting around 1900.
Excellent script and excellent English actors.
Strict focus on the story without the clutter of an open world.
Phenomenal sound design, especially for vehicles.
Clean and robust technical experience on PC (UE5)
Clever connections with predecessors for fans.
The plot is quite predictable for fans of the genre.
The shooting and stealth mechanics are solid, but conventional.
Occasionally, a weak and exploitable enemy AI.
Inconsistent interaction possibilities (for example, bottles)
The sustainability system for knives seems useless and artificial.
The grand racing mission is way too short.
The shooting and stealth mechanics are solid, but conventional.
Occasionally, a weak and exploitable enemy AI.
Inconsistent interaction possibilities (for example, bottles)
The sustainability system for knives seems useless and artificial.
The grand racing mission is way too short.
reviewed at 06/10/2025 - [read the full review on PixelCritics]
75
100
JVFrance
A true dive into the Italian Mafia
Very beautiful graphically
An excellent French version
An interesting and captivating story
An incredible soundtrack
Very beautiful graphically
An excellent French version
An interesting and captivating story
An incredible soundtrack
An anecdotal exploration
Way too many infiltration phases
A gameplay that is not very revolutionary
A repetitive gameplay loop
Some optimization problems
Way too many infiltration phases
A gameplay that is not very revolutionary
A repetitive gameplay loop
Some optimization problems
reviewed at 07/08/2025 - [read the full review on JVFrance]
15
20
GamerGen
Our hero, charismatic and humane The artistic direction, superb The staging, meticulous The script, strong and well-paced The assumed and mastered linearity
The sometimes clumsy gameplay The outdated animations Some visual bugs and optimization issues (on PC) The collectibles, without interest
reviewed at 01/01/1970 - [read the full review on GamerGen]
75
100
GamerClick
Narration and characters
Building the world and taking care of the details
I am sharing an audio file.
Building the world and taking care of the details
I am sharing an audio file.
Artificial intelligence of enemies
Animations and weapon feedback
Secondary contents and mechanisms are not very incisive.
Animations and weapon feedback
Secondary contents and mechanisms are not very incisive.
reviewed at 07/09/2025 - [read the full review on GamerClick]
72
100
Fortress Of Solitude
Riveting storyline and compelling characters
It feels like you're in Sicily in the 1900s
It feels like you're in Sicily in the 1900s
The promise of open world is deceptive
The gameplay is from the 1900s
The gameplay is from the 1900s
reviewed at 18/08/2025 - [read the full review on Fortress Of Solitude]
7
10
GameKult.com
A classic plot, but very effective
A very good gallery of characters
The dubbing in Sicilian is of very good quality.
An open world in the Mafia style, a bit empty, but very beautiful to explore.
A very good gallery of characters
The dubbing in Sicilian is of very good quality.
An open world in the Mafia style, a bit empty, but very beautiful to explore.
Some minor (but not harmful) technical issues
An outdated gameplay and an AI that needs to be reviewed
Phases of infiltration that are way too easy
An outdated gameplay and an AI that needs to be reviewed
Phases of infiltration that are way too easy
reviewed at 07/08/2025 - [read the full review on GameKult.com]
7
10
Multiplayer.it
A solo adventure, linear and with a well-told story.
There is everything one would expect from an action game with open world elements.
Excellent soundtrack and the dubbing in Sicilian is a great discovery.
The graphic design, especially for the characters, is sometimes remarkable.
There is everything one would expect from an action game with open world elements.
Excellent soundtrack and the dubbing in Sicilian is a great discovery.
The graphic design, especially for the characters, is sometimes remarkable.
All gameplay mechanics are derived and basic.
Knife duels quickly become repetitive.
Some minor technical issues related to youth
Someone could complain about the lack of a "traditional" Italian dubbing.
Knife duels quickly become repetitive.
Some minor technical issues related to youth
Someone could complain about the lack of a "traditional" Italian dubbing.
reviewed at 07/08/2025 - [read the full review on Multiplayer.it]
7
10
Hinsusta
Captivating and cinematic story
Attractive graphics and authentic atmosphere
Credible historical context
Occasional technical issues and performance fluctuations
Low replay value and linear structure
Short playing time and lack of long-term motivation
Attractive graphics and authentic atmosphere
Credible historical context
Occasional technical issues and performance fluctuations
Low replay value and linear structure
Short playing time and lack of long-term motivation
Occasional technical issues and performance fluctuations
Low replay value and linear structure
Short playing time and lack of long-term motivation
Low replay value and linear structure
Short playing time and lack of long-term motivation
reviewed at 08/08/2025 - [read the full review on Hinsusta]
7
10
Xbox Tavern
No "Pros & Cons" find at Xbox Tavern
reviewed at 11/08/2025 - [read the full review on Xbox Tavern]
7
10
Movies Games and Tech
No "Pros & Cons" find at Movies Games and Tech
reviewed at 12/08/2025 - [read the full review on Movies Games and Tech]
7
10
Numerama
Sicily as a backdrop!
Total immersion (especially with the Sicilian language)
A successful casting
Total immersion (especially with the Sicilian language)
A successful casting
Some technical hiccups
Gameplay without any ambition
Knife fights, what a pain.
Gameplay without any ambition
Knife fights, what a pain.
reviewed at 12/08/2025 - [read the full review on Numerama]
7
10
Pizza Fria
Coherent and well-executed narrative
Faithful and rich in historical details implementation
Dubbing in Sicilian with high-quality localization in Brazilian Portuguese
Cinematic audiovisual presentation
Faithful and rich in historical details implementation
Dubbing in Sicilian with high-quality localization in Brazilian Portuguese
Cinematic audiovisual presentation
Very limited freedom of exploration
Timid and repetitive game
Slow and imprecise weapons can be frustrating.
Timid and repetitive game
Slow and imprecise weapons can be frustrating.
reviewed at 12/08/2025 - [read the full review on Pizza Fria]
70
100
Console Tribe
Beautiful and historically accurate Sicilian setting
Solid, intense and well-paced narrative
Well-characterized characters and excellent acting performances
Soundtrack and dubbing in Sicilian with a great impact
Solid, intense and well-paced narrative
Well-characterized characters and excellent acting performances
Soundtrack and dubbing in Sicilian with a great impact
Sometimes predictable story
Unoriginal game with basic artificial intelligence
Repetitive and unsatisfying knife duels
Long loading time and sudden appearance of textures
Unoriginal game with basic artificial intelligence
Repetitive and unsatisfying knife duels
Long loading time and sudden appearance of textures
reviewed at 14/08/2025 - [read the full review on Console Tribe]
70
100
Complete Xbox
A well-written and strong storyline throughout
The Sicilian environment is rich in detail and stunningly presented
10-15 hour campaign, which is great if you?re a fan of shorter playthroughs
Fantastic voice acting and great cutscenes
The Sicilian environment is rich in detail and stunningly presented
10-15 hour campaign, which is great if you?re a fan of shorter playthroughs
Fantastic voice acting and great cutscenes
Combat is underwhelming and clunky
Stealth scenes are easy, and AI barely reacts
Whilst the game certainly looks nice, the visuals are dated
The most linear experience in the franchise
Stealth scenes are easy, and AI barely reacts
Whilst the game certainly looks nice, the visuals are dated
The most linear experience in the franchise
reviewed at 14/08/2025 - [read the full review on Complete Xbox]
7
10
VideoChums
No "Pros & Cons" find at VideoChums
reviewed at 15/08/2025 - [read the full review on VideoChums]
7
10
GameHope
An interesting (although predictable) story
A good staging
Well-written characters
Some really nice graphics
Sicilian dubbing to enhance immersion
A good staging
Well-written characters
Some really nice graphics
Sicilian dubbing to enhance immersion
Outdated gameplay phases (even if effective)
An AI often out of touch
Technical issues
An open world without activities
An AI often out of touch
Technical issues
An open world without activities
[7/10] reviewed at 18/08/2025 - Mafia : The Old Country (Xbox Series) [read the full review on GameHope]
[7/10] reviewed at 18/08/2025 - Mafia : The Old Country (PS5) [read the full review on GameHope]
[7/10] reviewed at 18/08/2025 - Mafia : The Old Country (PC) [read the full review on GameHope]
[7/10] reviewed at 18/08/2025 - Mafia : The Old Country (PS5) [read the full review on GameHope]
[7/10] reviewed at 18/08/2025 - Mafia : The Old Country (PC) [read the full review on GameHope]
14
20
JeuxActu.com
A compelling and immersive story that goes back to the DNA of the first Mafia game. Charismatic and well-written characters. The Sicilian atmosphere beautifully recreated. Attractive graphics thanks to Unreal Engine 5. Successful cinematic staging. A soundtrack that hits the mark. Perfect English voiceover and immersive Sicilian dubbing. Sold for 50? in digital format, 30? in physical format.
The French version, on the other hand, lacks conviction... Weak gunplay Completely outdated enemy AI Archaic and uninteresting infiltration Repetitive and predictable knife fights Stiff and outdated animations (15 years behind) Too much hand-holding (markers, wall vision, etc.) Story a bit too predictable, lacking boldness
reviewed at 21/08/2025 - [read the full review on JeuxActu.com]
7
10
tuttoteK
Cinematic narrative
The dubbing in Sicilian is a plus for the overall work.
Very faithful environments
Solid gameplay...
Good eye...
The dubbing in Sicilian is a plus for the overall work.
Very faithful environments
Solid gameplay...
Good eye...
...but very distracting
...but not in the foreground especially in animations.
Loading times are too long
Some repetitive mechanisms
...but not in the foreground especially in animations.
Loading times are too long
Some repetitive mechanisms
reviewed at 23/08/2025 - [read the full review on tuttoteK]
6
10
DigitalTrends
Lovingly authentic world
Impeccable performances
Impeccable performances
Barebones shooting and stealth
Clunky knife combat
Plot takes too long to get going
Clunky knife combat
Plot takes too long to get going
reviewed at 10/09/2025 - [read the full review on DigitalTrends]
6
10
GameSpot
No "Pros & Cons" find at GameSpot
reviewed at 07/08/2025 - [read the full review on GameSpot]
6
10
GameReactor
Great action sequences
Stylish setting
Good voice actors and music
Stylish setting
Good voice actors and music
Slow start
Unimaginative missions
Poor mix of open and linear design
Unimaginative missions
Poor mix of open and linear design
reviewed at 07/08/2025 - [read the full review on GameReactor]
6
10
GameInformer
No "Pros & Cons" find at GameInformer
reviewed at 07/08/2025 - [read the full review on GameInformer]
6
10
Push Square
Truly outstanding voice acting
Stunning scenery
Great attention to detail
Stunning scenery
Great attention to detail
Very predictable plot
Runs out of ideas fast
Underdeveloped gameplay
Runs out of ideas fast
Underdeveloped gameplay
reviewed at 11/08/2025 - [read the full review on Push Square]
3
5
EuroGamer.fr
No "Pros & Cons" find at EuroGamer.fr
reviewed at 13/08/2025 - [read the full review on EuroGamer.fr]
6
10
ActuGaming
A gripping story
The immersion carried by environments that exude the Mediterranean
Surprisingly realistic sets and textures
Horseback riding and driving
The immersion carried by environments that exude the Mediterranean
Surprisingly realistic sets and textures
Horseback riding and driving
A gameplay that is too classic
The AI of the enemy strawberries
The poorly exploited weapons, upgrades, and vehicles shop
The AI of the enemy strawberries
The poorly exploited weapons, upgrades, and vehicles shop
reviewed at 17/08/2025 - [read the full review on ActuGaming]
3
5
NME
Enzo?s descent into organised crime is gripping and believable
Compelling upgrade skill tree
The Sicilian island setting of San Celeste is absolutely stunning
Not a moment of the 15-hour single-player story is wasted
Compelling upgrade skill tree
The Sicilian island setting of San Celeste is absolutely stunning
Not a moment of the 15-hour single-player story is wasted
The skill level of enemies is wildly unpredictable
Guns and cars from the 1900s are authentic, but awkward to use
There?s no freedom to explore beyond the linear missions
Guns and cars from the 1900s are authentic, but awkward to use
There?s no freedom to explore beyond the linear missions
reviewed at 19/08/2025 - [read the full review on NME]
3
5
Geek Generation
No "Pros & Cons" find at Geek Generation
reviewed at 16/09/2025 - [read the full review on Geek Generation]
3
5
GamesCreed
The game's recreation of early 1900s Sicily is breathtaking and packed with historical detail that enhances immersion.
Enzo's story, though familiar, is emotionally compelling thanks to excellent motion capture and voice performances.
Driving mechanics are smooth, with a satisfying lineup of vintage vehicles and a return of the fan-favorite car encyclopedia.
The narrative-focused design keeps the pacing tight and avoids filler, making for a focused, cinematic experience.
Authentic sound design and period-accurate music enrich the world and elevate the storytelling.
Enzo's story, though familiar, is emotionally compelling thanks to excellent motion capture and voice performances.
Driving mechanics are smooth, with a satisfying lineup of vintage vehicles and a return of the fan-favorite car encyclopedia.
The narrative-focused design keeps the pacing tight and avoids filler, making for a focused, cinematic experience.
Authentic sound design and period-accurate music enrich the world and elevate the storytelling.
Combat mechanics, especially cover shooting and stealth, feel outdated and lack innovation or depth.
Knife fights, meant as boss encounters, become repetitive quickly and don't evolve over time.
The open world is visually stunning but lacks meaningful activities or interactivity outside the main missions.
Gameplay systems are largely recycled from Mafia: Definitive Edition with minimal iteration or improvement.
Players looking for modern AI complexity or replay value may find the 12-hour runtime too short for the price.
Knife fights, meant as boss encounters, become repetitive quickly and don't evolve over time.
The open world is visually stunning but lacks meaningful activities or interactivity outside the main missions.
Gameplay systems are largely recycled from Mafia: Definitive Edition with minimal iteration or improvement.
Players looking for modern AI complexity or replay value may find the 12-hour runtime too short for the price.
reviewed at 09/10/2025 - [read the full review on GamesCreed]
4
10
Well Played
Unique world and time period for the genre
Solid facial animations and performances
Solid facial animations and performances
Unengaging and predictable narrative
No single gameplay element is well made or fun
Poor implementation of genre systems
No single gameplay element is well made or fun
Poor implementation of genre systems
reviewed at 18/08/2025 - [read the full review on Well Played]
-
not scored
hyNerd.itNo "Pros & Cons" find at hyNerd.it
reviewed at 21/08/2024 - [read the full review on hyNerd.it]
-
not scored
Gaming TrendNarrative is absolutely brilliant
Voice cast nails the assignment
Visually-stunning world and cutscenes
Horse and car navigation is top-notch
That ending
Voice cast nails the assignment
Visually-stunning world and cutscenes
Horse and car navigation is top-notch
That ending
Open-world lacks substance in Explore mode
A few bugs
A few bugs
reviewed at 07/08/2025 - [read the full review on Gaming Trend]
-
not scored
GeekCultureNo "Pros & Cons" find at GeekCulture
reviewed at 07/08/2025 - [read the full review on GeekCulture]
-
not scored
JeuxVideo.comNo "Pros & Cons" find at JeuxVideo.com
reviewed at 07/08/2025 - [read the full review on JeuxVideo.com]
-
not scored
GamesWeltA strong atmosphere and a convincing mafia setting.
Successful character development and narrative density
beautiful environments, authentic atmosphere of Sicily
Exciting and surprising knife fights with a boss battle feel.
Solid shooting game, classic cover mechanics
Optional exploration, unlockable bonuses
Successful character development and narrative density
beautiful environments, authentic atmosphere of Sicily
Exciting and surprising knife fights with a boss battle feel.
Solid shooting game, classic cover mechanics
Optional exploration, unlockable bonuses
technically with some weaknesses (jerky movements, necessary restarts)
Some parts of the story are somewhat cliché.
Gestures, synchronization, and dialogues are not always successful.
few playful ideas, only superficial stealth
Some parts of the story are somewhat cliché.
Gestures, synchronization, and dialogues are not always successful.
few playful ideas, only superficial stealth
reviewed at 07/08/2025 - [read the full review on GamesWelt]
-
not scored
Computer BildNo "Pros & Cons" find at Computer Bild
reviewed at 08/08/2025 - [read the full review on Computer Bild]
-
not scored
ComputerBaseNo "Pros & Cons" find at ComputerBase
reviewed at 12/08/2025 - [read the full review on ComputerBase]
-
not scored
XboxygenNo "Pros & Cons" find at Xboxygen
reviewed at 12/08/2025 - [read the full review on Xboxygen]
-
not scored
TestingBuddiesBeautiful gaming world
Atmosphere of the early 20th century perfectly captured.
A very successful mafia story
The open world is dedicated to history.
Atmospheric soundtrack and professional dubbing
Innovative close combat system
Stealthy approach consistent
Horse racing as a cool addition
Atmosphere of the early 20th century perfectly captured.
A very successful mafia story
The open world is dedicated to history.
Atmospheric soundtrack and professional dubbing
Innovative close combat system
Stealthy approach consistent
Horse racing as a cool addition
Game duration is quite short.
Open world mainly in the background
Faces in the game a little stiff
No footprints in the sand
The possibilities of the DualSense are barely being used.
Open world mainly in the background
Faces in the game a little stiff
No footprints in the sand
The possibilities of the DualSense are barely being used.
reviewed at 11/08/2025 - [read the full review on TestingBuddies]
-
not scored
Game-eXperience.itNo "Pros & Cons" find at Game-eXperience.it
reviewed at 14/08/2025 - [read the full review on Game-eXperience.it]
-
not scored
CowCotLand.comNo "Pros & Cons" find at CowCotLand.com
reviewed at 14/08/2025 - [read the full review on CowCotLand.com]
-
not scored
Beyond GamingNo "Pros & Cons" find at Beyond Gaming
reviewed at 15/08/2025 - [read the full review on Beyond Gaming]
-
not scored
SmartworldExceptional setting
Captivating story
Very pleasant graphic rendering
Moving dubbing in Sicilian
Just longevity
Captivating story
Very pleasant graphic rendering
Moving dubbing in Sicilian
Just longevity
Difficulty too low
Sufficient solo game
The mediocre enemies
Services a little problematic
Sufficient solo game
The mediocre enemies
Services a little problematic
reviewed at 16/08/2025 - [read the full review on Smartworld]
-
not scored
FactorNews.comNo "Pros & Cons" find at FactorNews.com
reviewed at 26/08/2025 - [read the full review on FactorNews.com]
-
not scored
TweakersNo "Pros & Cons" find at Tweakers
reviewed at 27/08/2025 - [read the full review on Tweakers]
-
not scored
PlaySenseNo "Pros & Cons" find at PlaySense
reviewed at 15/08/2025 - [read the full review on PlaySense]
-
not scored
Future ZoneNo "Pros & Cons" find at Future Zone
reviewed at 01/09/2025 - [read the full review on Future Zone]
-
not scored
BeebomExcellent story and character development
Cutscenes you cannot skip
Great sound design and voice acting
Cutscenes you cannot skip
Great sound design and voice acting
Performance issues and clunky transitions
Limited gameplay loop and no replayability
Limited gameplay loop and no replayability
reviewed at 10/10/2025 - [read the full review on Beebom]
-
not scored
ConsollectionNo "Pros & Cons" find at Consollection
reviewed at 06/10/2025 - [read the full review on Consollection]
-
not scored
GeekiTNo "Pros & Cons" find at GeekiT
reviewed at 30/10/2025 - [read the full review on GeekiT]
Mafia The Old Country Users & Customers reviews
(affiliate links)
Reviews of youtubers
We find these video-Reviews & tests on youtube about Mafia The Old Country
Videos Tests Mafia The Old Country
Reviews of others Video Games Mafia
Test Mafia 2, Test Mafia Definitive Edition, Test Mafia II: Definitive Edition,... and find all reviews find for brand Mafia
Your review and rating for Mafia The Old Country:
Did you buy or tested this product ?
Infos et Conclusion
Mafia The Old Country review : Mafia The Old Country seems to be very good in the category of Video Games, the reviews are very positive overall for this product and the "Pros" are higher than "Cons".
What rating did Mafia The Old Country get?
An average rating of 3.7/5 with 58 ratings.What price ?
(Check the price: amazon)
Others Video Games:
[4.3/5] Dragon Quest I & II HD-2D Remake
[4.1/5] Hyrule Warriors Age of Imprisonment
[4.3/5] Arc Raiders
[3.9/5] Simon the Sorcerer Origins
[3.5/5] Football Manager 26
[4.3/5] Dragon Quest I & II HD-2D Remake
[4.1/5] Hyrule Warriors Age of Imprisonment
[4.3/5] Arc Raiders
[3.9/5] Simon the Sorcerer Origins
[3.5/5] Football Manager 26