4.5
5
25 ratings
Check all the 35 reviews find on Video Games Elden Ring Tarnished Edition, with the 25 ratings, comments, pros & cons from the reviewers.
Theses reviews and tests from Video Games magazines and websites give 25 ratings, we get this average rating to this Elden Ring product : 4.5/5.
En bref
- 35 reviews and opinions with 25 ratings for Elden Ring Tarnished Edition
- We obtain an average score of 4.5/5, or 89.32/100
- NDA on Reviews ? Please note that 20 reviews were published the same day 26/08/2026.
- This product got 3 times the maximum score in the reviews! This is pretty rare and shows that this Video Games is extremely successful!
Elden Ring Tarnished Edition ratings
25 Ratings ranked from best to worst, green to good grades, red to bad,
Average rating: 4.5/5.
Source: https://www.commentChoisir.fr
| 10/10 PCGames | 5/5 N-Gamz | 10/10 DisplayWeb |
| 95/100 NextN | 94/100 COGconnected | 94/100 Console Tribe |
| 93/100 Nintendúo | 9/10 GameSpew | 9/10 GameReactor |
| 9/10 Nintendo-Town | 9/10 Multiplayer.it | 90/100 TierraGamer |
| 9/10 Beyond Gaming | 9/10 VideoChums | 18/20 GamerGen |
| 9/10 Press Start | 9/10 GameHope | 9/10 Hinsusta |
| 9/10 GameScore.it | 8/10 GameBlog.fr | 80/100 JVFrance |
| 80/100 Switch-Actu | 8/10 XBoxEra | 8/10 Pizza Fria |
| 77/100 XBoxOrNot |
10 Preview or review without rating: 4players, Numerama, Nintendoros, Nintendo Life, JeuxVideo.com, MeriStation, GamesWelt, Vandal, CoupleOfGamer, NerdMovieProductions
For Video Games, ratings are sometimes different depending on the platform. Please refer to the good review...
Pros and cons for Elden Ring Tarnished Edition List of reviews and ratings
To better compare, we looked for you the advantages and disadvantages of Below and the notes given by specialized sites.
10
10
PCGames
reviewed at 26/08/2026 - [read the full review on PCGames]
5
5
N-Gamz
reviewed at 26/08/2026 - [read the full review on N-Gamz]
10
10
DisplayWeb
reviewed at 08/09/2026 - [read the full review on DisplayWeb]
95
100
NextN
A huge, detailed and filled with secrets open world, which constantly rewards exploration.
An exceptional gaming experience, with a deep combat system that allows for multiple styles and requires learning and improving.
Very strong performance on Nintendo Switch 2, holding up well in both portable and TV mode. The wait was worth it!
An exceptional gaming experience, with a deep combat system that allows for multiple styles and requires learning and improving.
Very strong performance on Nintendo Switch 2, holding up well in both portable and TV mode. The wait was worth it!
The difficulty can be very demanding, with a steep learning curve, especially for players who are not used to this type of experience.
We would have greatly appreciated having the cross-save feature, and even more the cross-play, even though we already knew that FromSoftware would not offer it.
We would have greatly appreciated having the cross-save feature, and even more the cross-play, even though we already knew that FromSoftware would not offer it.
reviewed at 26/08/2026 - [read the full review on NextN]
94
100
COGconnected
Full Elden Ring experience
Must-play DLC included
New classes and weapons
Runs well at 30fps
Must-play DLC included
New classes and weapons
Runs well at 30fps
Visual downgrade
Requires Switch online subscription for multiplayer
Not many options to adjust visuals or performance
Added content is relatively minor
Requires Switch online subscription for multiplayer
Not many options to adjust visuals or performance
Added content is relatively minor
reviewed at 03/09/2026 - [read the full review on COGconnected]
94
100
Console Tribe
reviewed at 18/09/2026 - [read the full review on Console Tribe]
93
100
Nintendúo
reviewed at 26/08/2026 - [read the full review on Nintendúo]
9
10
GameSpew
Visuals are great
Performance is solid
Includes base game, expansion, and additional content
It's Elden Ring
Performance is solid
Includes base game, expansion, and additional content
It's Elden Ring
Expansion's Blessing system is hit or miss
No performance mode
No performance mode
reviewed at 26/08/2026 - [read the full review on GameSpew]
9
10
GameReactor
Still one of the best-designed game worlds
Solid performance
New minor content
It feels incredible to play a game of this scale and calibre on a handheld device
Solid performance
New minor content
It feels incredible to play a game of this scale and calibre on a handheld device
It's not exactly great in every respect
The Joy-Cons are far from ideal for those intense boss battles
The Joy-Cons are far from ideal for those intense boss battles
reviewed at 26/08/2026 - [read the full review on GameReactor]
9
10
Nintendo-Town
Une direction artistique sublime
Un gameplay exigeant
Des musiques iconiques
Un monde ouvert fourni
Des boss formidables
Une durée de vie incroyable
Les nombreuses options pour créer le personnage de ses rêves
Une histoire riche en complexité pour ceux qui veulent creuser
Un gameplay exigeant
Des musiques iconiques
Un monde ouvert fourni
Des boss formidables
Une durée de vie incroyable
Les nombreuses options pour créer le personnage de ses rêves
Une histoire riche en complexité pour ceux qui veulent creuser
Pas de connectivité avec les autres consoles
reviewed at 26/08/2026 - [read the full review on Nintendo-Town]
9
10
Multiplayer.it
Elden Ring is still one of the best games currently available.
Playing on the go is an asset not to be underestimated.
The glance is still remarkable.
It is also very enjoyable on Nintendo Switch 2.
Playing on the go is an asset not to be underestimated.
The glance is still remarkable.
It is also very enjoyable on Nintendo Switch 2.
Limited to 30 frames per second, not always stable.
A few more pop-up episodes and some graphic bugs
No cross-saving or objectives, unlike other versions.
A few more pop-up episodes and some graphic bugs
No cross-saving or objectives, unlike other versions.
reviewed at 26/08/2026 - [read the full review on Multiplayer.it]
90
100
TierraGamer
reviewed at 26/08/2026 - [read the full review on TierraGamer]
9
10
Beyond Gaming
Open world that will take you away...
It continues to surprise you
Addictive experience
In one word: epic
It continues to surprise you
Addictive experience
In one word: epic
The tarnished pack for five euros does not include any "new" gameplay.
This can be overwhelming for the average Switch player.
This can be overwhelming for the average Switch player.
reviewed at 26/08/2026 - [read the full review on Beyond Gaming]
9
10
VideoChums
Absolutely top-notch core game with perhaps the best expansion ever made
Performs impressively well on Switch 2
Has some nice new goodies to check out
Performs impressively well on Switch 2
Has some nice new goodies to check out
Some parts have particularly poor performance and can be a bit jarring
reviewed at 26/08/2026 - [read the full review on VideoChums]
18
20
GamerGen
A particularly convincing Switch 2 adaptation The base game
+ Shadow of the Erdtree A huge amount of content The portable mode, particularly enjoyable The two new classes and additional bonuses Gameplay that is still just as addictive
+ Shadow of the Erdtree A huge amount of content The portable mode, particularly enjoyable The two new classes and additional bonuses Gameplay that is still just as addictive
Some performance drops, sometimes reduced display distance, some lighting effects and pop-in phenomena, no choice of graphic or performance mode. On a key card...
reviewed at 01/01/1970 - [read the full review on GamerGen]
9
10
Press Start
Enthralling and unique world concept, setting, and characters
Tightly designed open world that's as enjoyable to explore as it is rewarding
Some of FromSoftware's best boss fights yet
A visual spectacle in art direction and well-polished given the scope of the game
Tightly designed open world that's as enjoyable to explore as it is rewarding
Some of FromSoftware's best boss fights yet
A visual spectacle in art direction and well-polished given the scope of the game
Horseback combat is clunky
Co-op restrictions leave a lot to be desired
Co-op restrictions leave a lot to be desired
reviewed at 26/08/2026 - [read the full review on Press Start]
9
10
GameHope
A rather stable framerate (especially in portable mode)?
An honorable viewing distance
Large database
Elden Ring in portable mode
An honorable viewing distance
Large database
Elden Ring in portable mode
Except in certain situations (especially bosses)
Not easy to handle for large hands.
Necessarily a slight graphical downgrade
Not easy to handle for large hands.
Necessarily a slight graphical downgrade
reviewed at 31/08/2026 - [read the full review on GameHope]
9
10
Hinsusta
Complete Elden Ring experience including Shadow of the Erdtree
30 FPS surprisingly stable
Playable in an excellent way in portable mode.
Short loading times
New classes, weapons, armor
Partially visible pop-ins and technical compromises
30 FPS surprisingly stable
Playable in an excellent way in portable mode.
Short loading times
New classes, weapons, armor
Partially visible pop-ins and technical compromises
Partially visible pop-ins and technical compromises
reviewed at 03/09/2026 - [read the full review on Hinsusta]
9
10
GameScore.it
Masterful and rich in detail artistic direction, also enjoyable on the go;
Vast, stratified, and always rewarding world to explore;
Deep, punitive, and highly customizable combat;
Titanic longevity, enriched by the included expansion;
Solid and surprising technical conversion on Switch 2.
Vast, stratified, and always rewarding world to explore;
Deep, punitive, and highly customizable combat;
Titanic longevity, enriched by the included expansion;
Solid and surprising technical conversion on Switch 2.
Steep initial difficulty curve, requiring patience and dedication;
Light and sporadic drops in fluidity in areas rich in magical effects.
Sometimes chaotic camera against the most colossal enemies and in narrow places.
Light and sporadic drops in fluidity in areas rich in magical effects.
Sometimes chaotic camera against the most colossal enemies and in narrow places.
reviewed at 12/09/2026 - [read the full review on GameScore.it]
8
10
GameBlog.fr
reviewed at 26/08/2026 - [read the full review on GameBlog.fr]
80
100
JVFrance
Elden Ring everywhere, all the time.
One of the best open worlds ever created
Many possible builds
A real sense of adventure
Shadow of the Erdtree is included, a beautiful ending for Elden Ring.
One of the best open worlds ever created
Many possible builds
A real sense of adventure
Shadow of the Erdtree is included, a beautiful ending for Elden Ring.
The final act of the base game, which drags on a bit
A framerate that could be more stable
A launch price probably a little high for a game that is 4 years old
A framerate that could be more stable
A launch price probably a little high for a game that is 4 years old
reviewed at 26/08/2026 - [read the full review on JVFrance]
80
100
Switch-Actu
Gameplay is still as enjoyable.
Successful visuals on TV
An intact atmosphere
A gargantuan content!
Successful visuals on TV
An intact atmosphere
A gargantuan content!
A less convincing rendering in Portable
A framerate not always constant
A framerate not always constant
reviewed at 26/08/2026 - [read the full review on Switch-Actu]
8
10
XBoxEra
The best way to play Elden Ring natively on a handheld
The full Elden Ring experience in one package
C?mon?its Elden Ring!
The full Elden Ring experience in one package
C?mon?its Elden Ring!
Expensive for a four year old game
Performance issues dampen an excellent title
You may need to invest in controllers beyond the Joy Cons for the ideal experience
Performance issues dampen an excellent title
You may need to invest in controllers beyond the Joy Cons for the ideal experience
reviewed at 05/09/2026 - [read the full review on XBoxEra]
8
10
Pizza Fria
Constant refresh rate on the dock and laptop
Complete Elden Ring experience wherever we go
Can you maintain visual fidelity, despite the necessary sacrifices?
The complete edition offers a lot of content between the base game and the DLC.
Subtitled in Portuguese
Complete Elden Ring experience wherever we go
Can you maintain visual fidelity, despite the necessary sacrifices?
The complete edition offers a lot of content between the base game and the DLC.
Subtitled in Portuguese
You could have tried to maintain 45 to 60 frames per second in desktop mode.
Occasional frame drops in the most explosive moments, in both modes.
Could you add more exclusive content to differentiate the version and attract those who have already played on other consoles?
Occasional frame drops in the most explosive moments, in both modes.
Could you add more exclusive content to differentiate the version and attract those who have already played on other consoles?
reviewed at 12/09/2026 - [read the full review on Pizza Fria]
77
100
XBoxOrNot
Sick person's lifespan
Atmosphere of death
Some mind-blowing builds for our characters!
The Heavy Knight!
Atmosphere of death
Some mind-blowing builds for our characters!
The Heavy Knight!
A few snags here and there
We could have had a little interface upgrade!
We could have had a little interface upgrade!
reviewed at 02/09/2026 - [read the full review on XBoxOrNot]
-
not scored
4players reviewed at 26/08/2026 - [read the full review on 4players]
-
not scored
Numerama reviewed at 26/08/2026 - [read the full review on Numerama]
-
not scored
NintendorosA must-play game whether you are a fan of the genre or not.
Very well optimized for the platform.
He understands its great expansion and some new classes.
Very well optimized for the platform.
He understands its great expansion and some new classes.
Lack of dubbing in Spanish.
Some technical sacrifices.
Not much new content.
Some technical sacrifices.
Not much new content.
reviewed at 26/08/2026 - [read the full review on Nintendoros]
-
not scored
Nintendo Life reviewed at 26/08/2026 - [read the full review on Nintendo Life]
-
not scored
JeuxVideo.com reviewed at 26/08/2026 - [read the full review on JeuxVideo.com]
-
not scored
MeriStation reviewed at 27/08/2026 - [read the full review on MeriStation]
-
not scored
GamesWeltOrdered 2-port switch
contains the main game and the Shadow of the Erdtree DLC
More than 200 hours of concentrated gaming pleasure
a vast gaming world that offers an infinite number of discoveries
stimulates the desire to explore independently
Everywhere: wow! Wow! Wow!
excellent gameplay
Talented creative design
tons of secrets
Awesome level design inspired by Souls
Brilliant sound design
Bombastic music
and and and...
contains the main game and the Shadow of the Erdtree DLC
More than 200 hours of concentrated gaming pleasure
a vast gaming world that offers an infinite number of discoveries
stimulates the desire to explore independently
Everywhere: wow! Wow! Wow!
excellent gameplay
Talented creative design
tons of secrets
Awesome level design inspired by Souls
Brilliant sound design
Bombastic music
and and and...
only 30 fps
A slightly weaker graphics performance compared to PC, PS5, and Xbox Series.
No German version
can sometimes overwhelm beginners
A slightly weaker graphics performance compared to PC, PS5, and Xbox Series.
No German version
can sometimes overwhelm beginners
reviewed at 27/08/2026 - [read the full review on GamesWelt]
-
not scored
Vandal reviewed at 29/08/2026 - [read the full review on Vandal]
-
not scored
CoupleOfGamer reviewed at 07/09/2026 - [read the full review on CoupleOfGamer]
-
not scored
NerdMovieProductions reviewed at 08/09/2026 - [read the full review on NerdMovieProductions]
Elden Ring Tarnished Edition Users & Customers reviews
(affiliate links)
Reviews of youtubers
We find these video-Reviews & tests on youtube about Elden Ring Tarnished Edition
Videos Tests Elden Ring Tarnished Edition
Info and Conclusion
Elden Ring Tarnished Edition review : With an average rating of 4.5/5, you can buy Elden Ring Tarnished Edition with your eyes closed (or almost). The opinions of the testers seem unanimous !
What rating did Elden Ring Tarnished Edition get?
An average rating of 4.5/5 with 25 ratings.This Video Games got 3 times the maximum score in the reviews!
What price ?
(Check the price: amazon)
Reviews of others Video Games Elden Ring
Test Elden Ring Nightreign, Test Elden Ring Shadow of the Erdtree, Test Elden Ring,... and find all reviews find for brand Elden Ring
Your review and rating for Elden Ring Tarnished Edition:
Did you buy or tested this product ?
Others Video Games:
[4.3/5] Star Wars Galactic Racer
[3.7/5] Hellraiser Revival
[4.1/5] Dragon's Dogma Dark Arisen
[3.8/5] Valor Mortis
[4.3/5] Gears of War E-Day
[4.3/5] Star Wars Galactic Racer
[3.7/5] Hellraiser Revival
[4.1/5] Dragon's Dogma Dark Arisen
[3.8/5] Valor Mortis
[4.3/5] Gears of War E-Day