4.2
5
27 ratings
Check all the 38 reviews find on Laptops Asus ROG Strix Scar 18, with the 27 ratings, comments, pros & cons from the reviewers.
Theses reviews and tests from Laptops magazines and websites give 27 ratings, we get this average rating to this Asus product : 4.2/5.
En bref
- 38 reviews and opinions with 27 ratings for Asus ROG Strix Scar 18
- We obtain an average score of 4.2/5, or 83.41/100
- This product got 2 times the maximum score in the reviews! This is pretty rare and shows that this Laptops is extremely successful!
Asus ROG Strix Scar 18 ratings
27 Ratings ranked from best to worst, green to good grades, red to bad,
Average rating: 4.2/5.
Source: https://www.commentChoisir.fr
| 5/5 Les Numériques | 19/20 JeuxActu.com | 92/100 Fortress Of Solitude |
| 9/10 MKAU Gaming | 9/10 Journal du Geek | 9/10 NextGenTech |
| 9/10 FrAndroid | 89/100 NotebookCheck | 4/5 PCMag |
| 4/5 Tom's Hardware | 4/5 Laptop Mag | 4/5 Tom's Guide (US) |
| 8/10 Multiplayer.it | 4/5 Labo Fnac | 4/5 TechRadar |
| 4/5 Gadgets360 | 4/5 GamesRadar | 4/5 Geeknetic |
| 4/5 CowCotLand.com |
9 Preview or review without rating: Digital Citizen, 01net, Focus-Numerique, Vamers, PCWorld.com, DigitalTrends, Trusted Reviews, HardwareCooking, Wired
Pros and cons for Asus ROG Strix Scar 18 List of reviews and ratings
To better compare, we looked for you the advantages and disadvantages of Below and the notes given by specialized sites.
5
5
Les Numériques
Powerful processor.
Cooling system.
RTX 4080 performance.
Cooling system.
RTX 4080 performance.
Low-contrast slab.
Membrane keyboard.
Passable webcam.
Noise in Turbo mode.
Membrane keyboard.
Passable webcam.
Noise in Turbo mode.
reviewed at 16/03/2023 - [read the full review on Les Numériques]
4
5
Labo Fnac
Stratospheric CPU and GPU performance
The large 18-inch screen
"Reasonable" size for the format
RGB LEDs in all directions (if you like it)
Rather efficient dissipation system
The large 18-inch screen
"Reasonable" size for the format
RGB LEDs in all directions (if you like it)
Rather efficient dissipation system
The non-Mini-LED screen (unlike the Scar 16)
The noise of the three fans
No mechanical keyboard
Too many plastics for high-end
The noise of the three fans
No mechanical keyboard
Too many plastics for high-end
[4/5] reviewed at 24/03/2023 - Prise en main de l'Asus ROG Strix Scar 18 : puissance à gogo et très grand format [read the full review on Labo Fnac]
[5/5] reviewed at 27/06/2025 - Prise en main de l'Asus ROG Strix Scar 18 : un monstre absolu de puissance, capable d'évoluer ! [read the full review on Labo Fnac]
[5/5] reviewed at 27/06/2025 - Prise en main de l'Asus ROG Strix Scar 18 : un monstre absolu de puissance, capable d'évoluer ! [read the full review on Labo Fnac]
19
20
JeuxActu.com
Outstanding gaming and video editing performance (4K, even 8K) Extremely fast 2TB NVMe SSD Robust chassis and high-quality finish 18-inch 2.5K screen that offers beautiful image clarity Very efficient cooling system Wide touchpad and ergonomic palm rests LED strip under the chassis, we love it
Weak battery autonomy Mediocre webcam No SD card slot at this price
reviewed at 03/11/2025 - [read the full review on JeuxActu.com]
9
10
MKAU Gaming
Incredible Performance
Beautifully simple design with an amazing presence
Plenty of built in storage
Easy to use built in software
Beautifully simple design with an amazing presence
Plenty of built in storage
Easy to use built in software
The cooling system can get noisy while under extreme performance
reviewed at 14/07/2023 - [read the full review on MKAU Gaming]
9
10
Journal du Geek
No "Pros & Cons" find at Journal du Geek
reviewed at 11/03/2024 - [read the full review on Journal du Geek]
9
10
NextGenTech
Maximum power level
Imaboring and captivating experience
Imaboring and captivating experience
Low autonomy even on light tasks
reviewed at 01/06/2024 - [read the full review on NextGenTech]
9
10
FrAndroid
Monstrous performances
Most efficient cooling system
Nice screen in 16:10 aspect ratio
RTX 4090 to its TGP max / DLSS 3.0 convincing
Ideal games and resource-intensive activities
Most efficient cooling system
Nice screen in 16:10 aspect ratio
RTX 4090 to its TGP max / DLSS 3.0 convincing
Ideal games and resource-intensive activities
Imposing and bulky, not ideal to carry
Semi-plastic construction and staggering price
No biometrics/720p webcam only
Average battery life / bulky 330W charger
Semi-plastic construction and staggering price
No biometrics/720p webcam only
Average battery life / bulky 330W charger
reviewed at 04/03/2023 - Test de l'Asus ROG Strix SCAR 18 (G834J) : puissance de feu spectaculaire, prix et format considérables [read the full review on FrAndroid]
[9/10] reviewed at 04/05/2025 - Test de l'Asus ROG Strix Scar 18 (2025) : la RTX 5080 rugit sur mobile [read the full review on FrAndroid]
[9/10] reviewed at 04/05/2025 - Test de l'Asus ROG Strix Scar 18 (2025) : la RTX 5080 rugit sur mobile [read the full review on FrAndroid]
89
100
NotebookCheck
Impressive performance
Very fast 18-inch screen
USB-C with Power Delivery
Very fast 18-inch screen
USB-C with Power Delivery
GPU coil beep at more than 100 fps
Highly fingerprint-prone housing
No rear ports, USB-A only right (mouse right-handed in the path)
Only the rear USB-C is Thunderbolt
No brightness sensor
Very weak webcam
Highly fingerprint-prone housing
No rear ports, USB-A only right (mouse right-handed in the path)
Only the rear USB-C is Thunderbolt
No brightness sensor
Very weak webcam
[89/100] reviewed at 21/02/2023 - Test Asus ROG Strix Scar 18 2023 G834JY - Gaming Notebook mit RTX 4090 [read the full review on NotebookCheck]
[88/100] reviewed at 07/02/2024 - Asus ROG Strix Scar 18 (2024) im Test: Gaming-Laptop mit RTX 4090 und Mini-LED-Panel [read the full review on NotebookCheck]
[88/100] reviewed at 07/02/2024 - Asus ROG Strix Scar 18 (2024) im Test: Gaming-Laptop mit RTX 4090 und Mini-LED-Panel [read the full review on NotebookCheck]
92
100
Fortress Of Solitude
Updated yet minimalist design
LED lighting show
Next-generation hardware
Immersive audio
Brilliant gaming performance
Bright and bold IPS panel with 240Hz support
LED lighting show
Next-generation hardware
Immersive audio
Brilliant gaming performance
Bright and bold IPS panel with 240Hz support
On the pricey side
Needs some tweaking for best results
Battery life could be better
Needs some tweaking for best results
Battery life could be better
[92/100] reviewed at 24/02/2023 - Test ASUS ROG Strix Scar 18 ? A Gaming Beast [read the full review on Fortress Of Solitude]
[88/100] reviewed at 25/06/2025 - Test ASUS ROG Strix SCAR 18 (2025) Laptop ? A Gaming Monster That Blows Your Mind [read the full review on Fortress Of Solitude]
[88/100] reviewed at 25/06/2025 - Test ASUS ROG Strix SCAR 18 (2025) Laptop ? A Gaming Monster That Blows Your Mind [read the full review on Fortress Of Solitude]
4
5
PCMag
Extreme performance
Excellent gaming display
Semi-reasonable size and weight
Decent battery on iGPU
Excellent gaming display
Semi-reasonable size and weight
Decent battery on iGPU
Plastic construction
Expensive
Can become loud under intense work loads
Expensive
Can become loud under intense work loads
reviewed at 07/02/2023 - [read the full review on PCMag]
4
5
Tom's Guide (US)
+
Powerful components
+
Impressive 18-inch screen
+
Gorgeous RGB lighting
+
Quiet fans
Powerful components
+
Impressive 18-inch screen
+
Gorgeous RGB lighting
+
Quiet fans
-
Limited portability
-
Unimpressive keyboard
Limited portability
-
Unimpressive keyboard
reviewed at 15/02/2023 - [read the full review on Tom's Guide (US)]
4
5
TechRadar
Top-line GPU and CPU
Clever case design and cooling
Amazing screen
Clever case design and cooling
Amazing screen
Fans can get loud
Spine-bending weight
Almost unattainably expensive
Spine-bending weight
Almost unattainably expensive
reviewed at 08/05/2023 - [read the full review on TechRadar]
4
5
Gadgets360
Very good quality of construction.
Excellent performance
Clear and smooth display
Many software settings, potential for customization.
Excellent performance
Clear and smooth display
Many software settings, potential for customization.
Dear
Works hot even with occasional use.
Short battery life
Works hot even with occasional use.
Short battery life
reviewed at 22/05/2023 - [read the full review on Gadgets360]
4
5
Laptop Mag
No "Pros & Cons" find at Laptop Mag
[4/5] reviewed at 07/02/2023 - Test Asus ROG Strix Scar 18: A gaming kingslayer [read the full review on Laptop Mag]
[4/5] reviewed at 24/01/2024 - Test Asus ROG Strix Scar 18 (2024): Scrapes success with a platinum knife [read the full review on Laptop Mag]
[4/5] reviewed at 24/01/2024 - Test Asus ROG Strix Scar 18 (2024): Scrapes success with a platinum knife [read the full review on Laptop Mag]
8
10
Multiplayer.it
Massive power and performance in the game
Clean design, elegant lighting and thoughtful details
Good image quality
Clean design, elegant lighting and thoughtful details
Good image quality
Noticeable backlight bleeding at the corners of the screen
Despite the size, dissipation struggles to keep the Intel processor at bay
Limited autonomy and large footprint
Despite the size, dissipation struggles to keep the Intel processor at bay
Limited autonomy and large footprint
[8/10] reviewed at 28/02/2023 - ASUS ROG Strix SCAR 18: la recensione del potentissimo laptop gaming di nuova generazione [read the full review on Multiplayer.it]
[8/10] reviewed at 05/03/2024 - ASUS ROG Strix Scar 18: la recensione del portatile da gaming definitivo nella versione 2024 [read the full review on Multiplayer.it]
[8/10] reviewed at 05/03/2024 - ASUS ROG Strix Scar 18: la recensione del portatile da gaming definitivo nella versione 2024 [read the full review on Multiplayer.it]
4
5
GamesRadar
+
Top of the line components means incredible power
+
Super vivid and bright display
+
Full sized keyboard
+
Robust, well rounded speakers
+
Sophisticated cooling
Top of the line components means incredible power
+
Super vivid and bright display
+
Full sized keyboard
+
Robust, well rounded speakers
+
Sophisticated cooling
-
Not easily portable
-
Port placement is messy
-
Loud fans
-
Chassis design isn't for everyone
Not easily portable
-
Port placement is messy
-
Loud fans
-
Chassis design isn't for everyone
[4/5] reviewed at 15/08/2023 - Test Asus ROG Strix Scar 18: "if you need an 18-inch rig this is the one to buy" [read the full review on GamesRadar]
[3/5] reviewed at 08/02/2024 - Test Asus ROG Strix Scar 18 (2024): "an iterative update that doesn't quite top the performance charts" [read the full review on GamesRadar]
[4/5] reviewed at 17/04/2025 - Test Asus ROG Strix Scar 18 (2025): ?slicked back and grown up? [read the full review on GamesRadar]
[3/5] reviewed at 08/02/2024 - Test Asus ROG Strix Scar 18 (2024): "an iterative update that doesn't quite top the performance charts" [read the full review on GamesRadar]
[4/5] reviewed at 17/04/2025 - Test Asus ROG Strix Scar 18 (2025): ?slicked back and grown up? [read the full review on GamesRadar]
4
5
Geeknetic
Superlative performance in all aspects and components.
Core Ultra 9 275HX and RTX 5090 without power limitations.
Quality design and construction
64 GB of RAM and 4 TB of PCIe SSD in RAID 0
MiniLED 2K screen at 240 Hz
Excellent internal temperatures and, especially, outside.
Connectivity of all types, including Thunderbolt 5 and WiFi 7.
Core Ultra 9 275HX and RTX 5090 without power limitations.
Quality design and construction
64 GB of RAM and 4 TB of PCIe SSD in RAID 0
MiniLED 2K screen at 240 Hz
Excellent internal temperatures and, especially, outside.
Connectivity of all types, including Thunderbolt 5 and WiFi 7.
Very high price, far from the vast majority of wallets.
McAfee unwanted software
Considerable weight and height
McAfee unwanted software
Considerable weight and height
reviewed at 06/06/2025 - [read the full review on Geeknetic]
4
5
CowCotLand.com
Performances
Translation: Performances
Calibration of the slab
Powerful GPU
Powerful processor
Well-managed mini LED panel
Look totally bold and confident
Translation: Performances
Calibration of the slab
Powerful GPU
Powerful processor
Well-managed mini LED panel
Look totally bold and confident
Stay noisy
Autonomy
Color details
Rate
Autonomy
Color details
Rate
reviewed at 17/07/2025 - [read the full review on CowCotLand.com]
4
5
Tom's Hardware
No "Pros & Cons" find at Tom's Hardware
[4/5] reviewed at 07/02/2023 - Test Asus ROG Strix Scar 18: 13th Gen Core and RTX 4090 Go Big [read the full review on Tom's Hardware]
[3/5] reviewed at 12/01/2024 - Test Asus ROG Strix Scar 18 (2024): Beautiful screen, but needs refinement. [read the full review on Tom's Hardware]
[3/5] reviewed at 12/01/2024 - Test Asus ROG Strix Scar 18 (2024): Beautiful screen, but needs refinement. [read the full review on Tom's Hardware]
-
not scored
Digital CitizenNo "Pros & Cons" find at Digital Citizen
reviewed at 17/02/2023 - [read the full review on Digital Citizen]
-
not scored
01netNo "Pros & Cons" find at 01net
reviewed at 23/02/2023 - [read the full review on 01net]
-
not scored
Focus-NumeriqueNo "Pros & Cons" find at Focus-Numerique
reviewed at 18/03/2023 - [read the full review on Focus-Numerique]
-
not scored
VamersNo "Pros & Cons" find at Vamers
reviewed at 05/06/2023 - [read the full review on Vamers]
-
not scored
PCWorld.comExcellent CPU and GPU performance
Bright, vibrant Mini-LED display
Good connectivity including Thunderbolt 4 and 2.5G Ethernet
MSRP is attractive for the performance delivered
Bright, vibrant Mini-LED display
Good connectivity including Thunderbolt 4 and 2.5G Ethernet
MSRP is attractive for the performance delivered
Unimpressive look and feel
Mediocre keyboard and small touchpad
Thick, bulky, and heavy
Simple webcam and microphone, no biometric login
Mediocre keyboard and small touchpad
Thick, bulky, and heavy
Simple webcam and microphone, no biometric login
reviewed at 26/01/2024 - [read the full review on PCWorld.com]
-
not scored
DigitalTrendsExceptional gaming performance
It's rarely loud in gaming scenarios
Surprisingly decent battery life
Great keyboard
Stunning mini-LED display
It's rarely loud in gaming scenarios
Surprisingly decent battery life
Great keyboard
Stunning mini-LED display
Awkward port layout
Plenty of screen flex
Insanely big and expensive
Plenty of screen flex
Insanely big and expensive
reviewed at 05/02/2024 - Test Asus ROG Strix Scar 18: as ridiculous as I hoped it would be [read the full review on DigitalTrends]
reviewed at 12/05/2025 - Test Asus ROG Strix SCAR 18 (2025): looking great, and playing just as well [read the full review on DigitalTrends]
reviewed at 12/05/2025 - Test Asus ROG Strix SCAR 18 (2025): looking great, and playing just as well [read the full review on DigitalTrends]
-
not scored
Trusted ReviewsNo "Pros & Cons" find at Trusted Reviews
reviewed at 23/02/2024 - [read the full review on Trusted Reviews]
-
not scored
HardwareCookingNo "Pros & Cons" find at HardwareCooking
reviewed at 25/02/2024 - [read the full review on HardwareCooking]
-
not scored
WiredNo "Pros & Cons" find at Wired
reviewed at 15/04/2024 - [read the full review on Wired]
Asus ROG Strix Scar 18 Users & Customers reviews
(affiliate links)
Reviews of others Laptops Asus
Test Asus TUF Gaming F16, Test Asus Chromebook CX14, Test Asus TUF Gaming A18,... and find all reviews find for brand Asus
Your review and rating for Asus ROG Strix Scar 18:
Did you buy or tested this product ?
Infos et Conclusion
Asus ROG Strix Scar 18 review : With an average rating of 4.2/5, you can buy Asus ROG Strix Scar 18 with your eyes closed (or almost). The opinions of the testers seem unanimous !
What rating did Asus ROG Strix Scar 18 get?
An average rating of 4.2/5 with 27 ratings.This Laptops got 2 times the maximum score in the reviews!
What price ?
(Check the price: amazon)
Others Laptops:
[3.7/5] HP Victus 15
[4.2/5] Lenovo Legion 5
[3.7/5] Lenovo LOQ 15
[4.6/5] Apple MacBook Pro 14
[4.2/5] Lenovo Yoga 9i
[3.7/5] HP Victus 15
[4.2/5] Lenovo Legion 5
[3.7/5] Lenovo LOQ 15
[4.6/5] Apple MacBook Pro 14
[4.2/5] Lenovo Yoga 9i