3.8
5
22 ratings
Review Islanders
Date: (Last saved review: ) - Review: CommentChoisir.fr
Check all the 23 reviews find on Video Games Islanders , with the 22 ratings, comments, pros & cons from the reviewers.
Theses reviews and tests from Video Games magazines and websites give 22 ratings, we get this average rating to this Islanders product : 3.8/5.
Islanders review : Islanders seems to be very good in the category of Video Games, the reviews are very positive overall for this product and the "Pros" are higher than "Cons".
Islanders ratings
22 Ratings ranked from best to worst, green to good grades, red to bad,
Average rating: 3.8/5.
Source: https://www.commentChoisir.fr
| 9/10 TechRaptor | 9/10 GameSpew | 9/10 Xbox Tavern | 17/20 N-Gamz |
| 8/10 Nintendo World Report | 80/100 Switch-Actu | 4/5 EuroGamer.fr | 8/10 Push Square |
| 8/10 Pure Nintendo | 8/10 Checkpoint Gaming | 8/10 TheSixthAxis | 78/100 COGconnected |
| 7/10 Nintendo-Town | 7/10 JVFrance | 7/10 GameReactor | 60/100 Gaming Trend |
| 6/10 Game-eXperience.it | 5/10 VideoChums |
1 Preview or review without rating: Phenixx Gaming
For Video Games, ratings are sometimes different depending on the platform. Please refer to the good review...
Pros and cons for Islanders List of reviews and ratings
To better compare, we looked for you the advantages and disadvantages of Below and the notes given by specialized sites.
9
10
Xbox Tavern
Simple inputs
Relaxed play that does not compromise the complexity
Endless delight in seeing city growth
Enchanting soundtrack
Relaxed play that does not compromise the complexity
Endless delight in seeing city growth
Enchanting soundtrack
Real problems with stability
This game may have ruined me for all games going forward
My Fiance is upset by my fixation on this game
This game may have ruined me for all games going forward
My Fiance is upset by my fixation on this game
[9/10] reviewed at 03/09/2021 - Test Islanders [read the full review on Xbox Tavern]
[10/10] reviewed at 19/07/2025 - Test ISLANDERS: New Shores [read the full review on Xbox Tavern]
[10/10] reviewed at 19/07/2025 - Test ISLANDERS: New Shores [read the full review on Xbox Tavern]
9
10
GameSpew
No "Pros & Cons" find for this reviewer.
reviewed at 30/08/2021 - [read the full review on GameSpew]
17
20
N-Gamz
No "Pros & Cons" find for this reviewer.
reviewed at 28/08/2021 - [read the full review on N-Gamz]
80
100
Switch-Actu
No "Pros & Cons" find for this reviewer.
reviewed at 14/08/2021 - [read the full review on Switch-Actu]
4
5
EuroGamer.fr
No "Pros & Cons" find for this reviewer.
reviewed at 19/08/2021 - [read the full review on EuroGamer.fr]
8
10
Push Square
Instantly accessible and relaxing
Super addictive
Lovely art direction
Super addictive
Lovely art direction
Controls can be a tiny bit fiddly
reviewed at 26/08/2021 - [read the full review on Push Square]
8
10
Pure Nintendo
No "Pros & Cons" find for this reviewer.
reviewed at 30/09/2021 - [read the full review on Pure Nintendo]
8
10
Nintendo World Report
Abandoning islands makes each playthrough feel fresh
City Building with a zenlike puzzle twist
Great value for pick up and play sessions
City Building with a zenlike puzzle twist
Great value for pick up and play sessions
Controls can be a bit irritating
Lack of instructions for building types
Lack of instructions for building types
[8/10] reviewed at 13/08/2021 - Test ISLANDERS: Console Edition (Switch) [read the full review on Nintendo World Report]
[8/10] reviewed at 08/07/2025 - Test ISLANDERS: New Shores (Switch) [read the full review on Nintendo World Report]
[8/10] reviewed at 08/07/2025 - Test ISLANDERS: New Shores (Switch) [read the full review on Nintendo World Report]
8
10
Checkpoint Gaming
Improved visuals while retaining the cozy vibe
New features adds a new challenge to what was already a successful game
Familiar gameplay mechanics for those returning
New features adds a new challenge to what was already a successful game
Familiar gameplay mechanics for those returning
It feels like you're playing metal detector to collect the most points
reviewed at 16/07/2025 - [read the full review on Checkpoint Gaming]
8
10
TheSixthAxis
Addictively relaxing
Chilled atmospheric soundtrack
Lovely visuals
Quick tutorial and easily accessible gameplay
Chilled atmospheric soundtrack
Lovely visuals
Quick tutorial and easily accessible gameplay
Hit and miss zoom
Too subtle selection highlight
Too subtle selection highlight
reviewed at 17/07/2025 - [read the full review on TheSixthAxis]
78
100
COGconnected
Chill, relaxing vibe
Pretty visuals
No end game
Pretty visuals
No end game
Cities lack life
Controls can be finicky
No end game
Controls can be finicky
No end game
reviewed at 01/09/2021 - [read the full review on COGconnected]
7
10
JVFrance
No "Pros & Cons" find for this reviewer.
reviewed at 05/09/2021 - [read the full review on JVFrance]
7
10
GameReactor
Relaxing
Entertaining
Cosy design
Entertaining
Cosy design
Inconsistent building grid
Few new features
Rogue elements become repetitive on the first few islands
Few new features
Rogue elements become repetitive on the first few islands
reviewed at 08/07/2025 - [read the full review on GameReactor]
7
10
Nintendo-Town
Une suite réussie parfaite pour les joueurs cosy
Cosy? mais aussi très stratégique
Un tableau des scores pour se mesurer aux joueurs dans le monde !
Un côté roguelike (aléatoire) intéressant
Des graphismes qui rendent nos îles très jolies
Une bande-son relaxante à souhait
Très addictif !
Cosy? mais aussi très stratégique
Un tableau des scores pour se mesurer aux joueurs dans le monde !
Un côté roguelike (aléatoire) intéressant
Des graphismes qui rendent nos îles très jolies
Une bande-son relaxante à souhait
Très addictif !
Un contenu finalement assez léger
Un sentiment de répétitivité
Seulement deux modes qui ne renouvellent que très peu l?expérience
L?aléatoire omniprésent ne se mélange pas très bien avec le score mondial
Un sentiment de répétitivité
Seulement deux modes qui ne renouvellent que très peu l?expérience
L?aléatoire omniprésent ne se mélange pas très bien avec le score mondial
[7/10] reviewed at 26/08/2021 - Islanders ? Console Édition (Nintendo Switch) ? Le test [read the full review on Nintendo-Town]
[7/10] reviewed at 08/07/2025 - Islanders: New Shores (Nintendo Switch) ? Le test [read the full review on Nintendo-Town]
[7/10] reviewed at 08/07/2025 - Islanders: New Shores (Nintendo Switch) ? Le test [read the full review on Nintendo-Town]
60
100
Gaming Trend
Arcade mode is neat
Sandbox is fun
Sandbox is fun
Controls are cumbersome
Frequently imprecise
Frequently imprecise
reviewed at 26/09/2023 - [read the full review on Gaming Trend]
6
10
Game-eXperience.it
No "Pros & Cons" find for this reviewer.
reviewed at 30/09/2023 - [read the full review on Game-eXperience.it]
9
10
TechRaptor
Smart Combo of City Building and Puzzles
Fun New Elements Constantly Introduced
Beautiful
Fun New Elements Constantly Introduced
Beautiful
Sometimes Too Predictable
[9/10] reviewed at 04/04/2019 - Test Islanders ? If You're Fond of Sand Dunes and Salty Air [read the full review on TechRaptor]
[6/10] reviewed at 04/07/2025 - Test Islanders: New Shores - Desire Lines [read the full review on TechRaptor]
[6/10] reviewed at 04/07/2025 - Test Islanders: New Shores - Desire Lines [read the full review on TechRaptor]
5
10
VideoChums
Relaxing gameplay with nifty scoring that's easy to master without much effort
The islands are pretty cute
Chill music will put you to sleep
The islands are pretty cute
Chill music will put you to sleep
It's a bit too simple and repetitive and not much strategy is required
Could use more lively animation
Inconsistent placement rules
Could use more lively animation
Inconsistent placement rules
reviewed at 28/08/2021 - [read the full review on VideoChums]
-
not scored
Phenixx GamingNo "Pros & Cons" find for this reviewer.
reviewed at 14/07/2025 - [read the full review on Phenixx Gaming]
Islanders Users & Customers reviews
(affiliate links)
Reviews of youtubers
We find these video-Reviews & tests on youtube about Islanders
Videos Tests Islanders
Your review and rating for Islanders:
Did you buy or tested this product ?
Infos et Conclusion
What rating did Islanders get?
An average rating of 3.8/5 with 22 ratings.What price ?
Islanders is available at the price of 14.95€. (Check the price: amazon)
Others Video Games:
[4.2/5] Ninja Gaiden Ragebound
[3/5] Lord of the Rings Tales of the Shire
[3.4/5] Killing Floor 3
[3.9/5] Demon Slayer The Hinokami Chronicles 2
[3.9/5] Wuchang Fallen Feathers
[4.2/5] Ninja Gaiden Ragebound
[3/5] Lord of the Rings Tales of the Shire
[3.4/5] Killing Floor 3
[3.9/5] Demon Slayer The Hinokami Chronicles 2
[3.9/5] Wuchang Fallen Feathers