Check all the 35 reviews find on Video Games Gothic 1 Remake, with the 23 ratings, comments, pros & cons from the reviewers.
Theses reviews and tests from Video Games magazines and websites give 23 ratings, we get this average rating to this Gothic product : 3.6/5.
En bref
- 35 reviews and opinions with 23 ratings for Gothic 1 Remake
- We obtain an average score of 3.6/5, or 72.7/100
Gothic 1 Remake ratings
Source: https://www.commentChoisir.fr
| 9/10 Hinsusta | 9/10 Niche Gamer | 85/100 Games.ch |
| 8/10 GamersGlobal | 8/10 PCGames | 8/10 Multiplayer.it |
| 8/10 GameInformer | 8/10 Beyond Gaming | 8/10 Comunidad Xbox |
| 8/10 GameScore.it | 4/5 TheXboxHub | 79/100 Console Tribe |
| 7/10 GameSpace | 7/10 Xbox-Mag | 7/10 PixelCritics |
| 7/10 ZTGD | 68/100 COGconnected | 60/100 PCGamer |
| 3/5 Absolute Geeks | 6/10 GamingBolt | 3/5 Geeks By Girls |
| 5/10 Push Square | 5/10 Well Played |
For Video Games, ratings are sometimes different depending on the platform. Please refer to the good review...
Pros and cons for Gothic 1 Remake List of reviews and ratings
To better compare, we looked for you the advantages and disadvantages of Below and the notes given by specialized sites.


Beautifully designed graphics with love
Modernized combat system, significantly better and smoother.
Story faithful to the original, atmosphere and world design
Atmospheric soundtrack
An excellent new glossary system in the menu replaces the lack of "getting started".
Occasional user interface hang-ups in the inventory, asynchronous audio tracks or delayed quest texts.
Small issues with AI and animations
Small malfunctions of AI and animations


Expanded elements in the story and various quest content
Refined combat that?s more fluid than its predecessor
Meaningful progression and no hand holding


The detailed world invites exploration.
The quests and main plot can be approached in different ways.
Inexperienced players will feel very disoriented.


The players are hardly taken by the hand (it is also no coincidence that he is on the right)
Four levels of difficulty (plus other customization options)
Unlimited manual backup
The automatic backup function protects (limits) against a more significant loss of progress.
New organized combat system that clearly surpasses the old one...
Many comfort improvements (including the ability to cook multiple pieces of meat at the same time)
Large game world significantly expanded with new NPCs, quests, and completely new areas (for example, an abandoned mine)
A very good story with many adaptations that keep the game fresh even for connoisseurs.
Motivating progression system
Some new skills and systems, mainly optional (climbing, cooking, horseback riding, etc.)
High solo playtime (30 hours and more)
A high replay value thanks to different levels.
Very beautiful, detailed graphics.
Seamless loading time free explorable world
Good lighting system that creates an ambiance during the smooth transition from day to night.
Some very cool weather effects (night storms can be scary sometimes)
Superb world architecture very focused on originality
Virtual appearance of "In Extremo" still there...
Very good pronunciation in German
Fantastic soundtrack
Generally good sound effects, the wind and weather are particularly realistic.
Players are hardly taken by the hand (it is not by chance that it is on the left either)
No tutorial
No sorting function, not all items are stackable of the same type.
...but cannot compete with those of FF16, Nioh 3 and Co.
At first, it is very difficult, then sometimes it becomes a bit too easy afterwards.
Far too few beds being used effectively.
Occasional crashes
A few small isolated bugs but very annoying.
...but in a different, weaker version


He maintains the philosophy of the original
This provides great satisfaction.
A little more courage would not have displeased us.
There are a few technical issues.


Organic gaming world
Unique oldschool style game
Very strong in terms of audiovisual.
Sometimes ambiguous missions
Technical problems and malfunctions


Immersive, stimulating, and with a great sense of progression.
Excellent visual work while preserving the essence of the Colony intact.
Improvements in quality of life such as the new inventory and modernized systems.
Soundtrack, atmosphere, and expansion of the universe very well resolved.
Occasional errors with the Quick Resume function on Xbox Series.
Very demanding learning curve in the first few hours that can discourage some players.
Some mechanics continue to show the weight of their classical origin.


Modern gameplay in management, complex and rewarding in progression;
Building a wonderful world, with factions and routines that are still surprising today;
Available in Italian language.
Sometimes imprecise fighting in the most hectic situations;
Some technical rigidities still noticeable.


Story and dialogue
Updated visuals
New voice cast


Beautiful story and setting
Immense work of aesthetic and artistic rejuvenation...
Combat system anchored in the past
... but there is more than one technical puzzle


Original Vibe
Recreated World
Improved UI UX
World Expansion
Visual Issues
Rough Animations
Unsatisfying Battle System
Unrewarding Exploration


Atypical and captivating universe
Old-school RPG
Pleasant sound environment
Constant testing?
Ask for courage and a lot of patience
A little rigid
Many bugs and crashes tarnish the experience.


The graphical improvement with Unreal Engine 5 turns Khorinas into a truly remarkable place.
The combat system evolves visibly and satisfactorily with increasing skill.
The completely reworked dialogues are much better than the original.
Giving up the minimap and quest markers forces a true confrontation with the world.
New content such as climbing and horseback riding integrate perfectly.
The extensions in the quest log and glossary help without being intrusive.
The main story shifts into a standard narrative of "saving the world".
The pace of the quest slows significantly in the second half.
Bugs and AI failures are more frequent than they should be in 2026.
The physical edition is unplayable without the Day One patch.


Improved environments are cool
Pacing is off
Game is buggy at times


Interesting premise
Combat eventually becomes fun
Unique upgrade systems and mechanics
Unfriendly systems
Performance issues and bugs
Inconsistent writing and performances




Old-school difficulty
All the elements of a good RPG are brought together
Beautiful atmosphere
Original title identity respected
No quest marker
The novice player may feel lost and discouraged.
Some accessibility options are missing.


Complex systems-based mechanics
Compelling world and setting
Satisfying eventual power curve
Serious graphical, audio bugs
Clunky combat is overly punishing
Simplistic story, characters


An attractive, often sublime, presentation of an ugly world
Tying progression to faction and character alignment is novel
Memorable simulation of a fantasy prison colony
Punitive challenge that runs counter to the game?s ideas of choice and roleplay
Poor directional guidance and lacklustre waypointing lead to aimless backtracking
Over-reliance on save scumming
Significant innovations that integrate harmoniously
Heroic progress motivating from person to machine
A remake with a lot of love and respect for the original.
Balance sometimes frustrates even for gothic standards.
Does not always work properly on less powerful computers.
reviewed at 05/06/2026 - Video: Das Gothic Remake macht's uns im Test nicht leicht! [read the full review on GameStar]
reviewed at 05/06/2026 - Plus - Test: Gothic Remake im Test - Das Rollenspiel macht es uns brutal schwer - aber unser erstes Fazit nach 35 Stunden steht fest [read the full review on GameStar]
Visual update is spectacular
+
Tough but rewarding gameplay
+
Intriguing story keeps you invested
Repeated, nonsensical barks shatter immersion
-
Some contrived quests test patience to breaking point
-
Janky, and not always in a fun way
Gothic 1 Remake Users & Customers reviews
(affiliate links)
Reviews of youtubers
We find these video-Reviews & tests on youtube about Gothic 1 Remake
Videos Tests Gothic 1 RemakeInfo and Conclusion
Gothic 1 Remake review : Gothic 1 Remake seems to be very good in the category of Video Games, the reviews are very positive overall for this product and the "Pros" are higher than "Cons".
What rating did Gothic 1 Remake get?
An average rating of 3.6/5 with 23 ratings.What price ?
(Check the price: amazon)
Reviews of others Video Games Gothic
Test Gothic 2 Complete Classic, Test Gothic Classic, Test Gothic 3,... and find all reviews find for brand Gothic
Your review and rating for Gothic 1 Remake:
[4.4/5] Denshattack!
[4.2/5] Splatoon Raiders
[3.5/5] The Mound Omen of Cthulhu
[3.8/5] D-topia
[3.9/5] Moss The Forgotten Relic