<< latest reviews
3.7
5
41 ratings

Review Mafia The Old Country

Date: (Last saved review: ) -

Check all the 55 reviews find on Video Games Mafia The Old Country, with the 41 ratings, comments, pros & cons from the reviewers.
Theses reviews and tests from Video Games magazines and websites give 41 ratings, we get this average rating to this Mafia product : 3.7/5.
Mafia The Old Country review : Mafia The Old Country seems to be very good in the category of Video Games, the reviews are very positive overall for this product and the "Pros" are higher than "Cons".


For Video Games, ratings are sometimes different depending on the platform. Please refer to the good review...

Mafia The Old Country ratings

41 Ratings ranked from best to worst, green to good grades, red to bad, Average rating: 3.7/5
5/5 TechPowerUp
9/10 Areajugones
90/100 Generación Xbox
9/10 MKAU Gaming
85/100 COGconnected
81/100 Games.ch
8/10 PCGames
8/10 wccftech
8/10 GamersGlobal
8/10 Checkpoint Gaming
8/10 GamingBolt
8/10 Vandal
8/10 Journal du Geek
8/10 GameOver
8/10 Xbox-Mag
4/5 TheXboxHub
4/5 N-Gamz
75/100 JVFrance
15/20 GamerGen
72/100 Fortress Of Solitude
7/10 GameKult.com
7/10 Multiplayer.it
7/10 Hinsusta
7/10 Xbox Tavern
7/10 Movies Games and Tech
7/10 Numerama
7/10 Pizza Fria
70/100 Console Tribe
70/100 Complete Xbox
7/10 VideoChums
7/10 GameHope
6/10 GameSpot
6/10 GameReactor
6/10 GameInformer
6/10 Push Square
3/5 EuroGamer.fr
6/10 ActuGaming
4/10 Well Played
Preview or review without rating: hyNerd.it, Gaming Trend, GeekCulture, TierraGamer, JeuxVideo.com, GamesWelt, Computer Bild, ComputerBase, Xboxygen, TestingBuddies, Game-eXperience.it, CowCotLand.com, Beyond Gaming

Pros and cons for Mafia The Old Country List of reviews and ratings

To better compare, we looked for you the advantages and disadvantages of Below and the notes given by specialized sites.

5
5

TechPowerUp
[5/5] reviewed at 11/08/2025 - Test Mafia: The Old Country Performance Benchmark - 30+ GPUs Tested...[read the full review on TechPowerUp]
8
10

PCGames
[8/10] reviewed at 09/09/2024 - Mafia trifft auf Tatortreiniger: Das wahrscheinlich blutigste Spiel des Jahres...[read the full review on PCGames]
[9/10] reviewed at 07/08/2025 - Mafia: The Old Country im Test - zwischen Messerduellen, Mafia-Ehre und emotionaler Story...[read the full review on PCGames]
9
10

Areajugones
Absolutely masterful Spanish dubbing
A cinematic narrative that moves you from the very first minute.
Enzo Favala as an authentically human protagonist
Graphs that constantly surprise
A cohesive experience from start to finish
Impeccable narrative pace without artificial filler
Vehicle management is something that needs improvement.
The shooting game could be slightly improved.
[9/10] reviewed at 07/08/2025 - Análisis de Mafia: The Old Country - Una propuesta que no podrás rechazar...[read the full review on Areajugones]
90
100

Generación Xbox
Cinematic staging: carefully recreates Sicily in 1900 with attention to detail and remarkable artistic direction.
Captivating story: Enzo's descent into organized crime is told with strength and authenticity.
Reduced price, Spanish dubbing and without filling.
Marked linearity: although intentional, this can leave a feeling of lack of freedom or exploration between missions.
Irregular enemy AI: some enemies react clumsily in certain shootouts or remain exposed in an illogical manner.
[90/100] reviewed at 07/08/2025 - Análisis de Mafia: The Old Country, un viaje a donde empezó todo...[read the full review on Generación Xbox]
9
10

MKAU Gaming
Beautiful, detailed, atmospheric graphics that capture the Sicilian setting perfectly
Immersive sound design with top-tier voice acting
Smooth, responsive controls that allow fluid movements
Strong, emotionally engaging narrative filled with themes of loyalty, power and sacrifice
Subtle environmental touches that bring the world to life
Occasional character model glitches, such as the bizarre stretching of field workers
Gun movement sometimes felt a little quick
[9/10] reviewed at 11/08/2025 - Test Mafia: The Old Country (Xbox Series X) ?...[read the full review on MKAU Gaming]
85
100

COGconnected
Well-Paced Story
Overall Presentation
Focused, Linear Adventure
Formulaic Mission Structure
Open World is Pointless
A Little Repetitive
[85/100] reviewed at 11/08/2025 - Test Mafia: The Old Country ? Blood, Loyalty and Legacy...[read the full review on COGconnected]
81
100

Games.ch
A very well-crafted story, mainly of first-class quality.
Varied game and overall excellent pace
Atmospheric and vast gaming world
Atmospheric soundtrack and powerful sound effects
A very good quality of voice (also in German)
Despite some minor flaws, detailed and fabulous photorealistic graphics (PC)
Appropriate game length for a story-focused game (around 15 hours in "Normal" mode)
Weak AI (especially in stealth mode)
Game design can sometimes be conservative or even outdated.
[81/100] reviewed at 07/08/2025 - Test Mafia: The Old Country - Test /...[read the full review on Games.ch]
8
10

wccftech
Great visuals and authenticity
Excellent narrative and characters, though lacking major twists from the usual Mafia plot fare
Solid gameplay...
...that is however not as good as the genre's best
No real exploration or side activities
[8/10] reviewed at 07/08/2025 - Test Mafia: The Old Country ? A Fine Sicilian Mafia Story...[read the full review on wccftech]
8
10

GamersGlobal
Good tutorial
Three selectable levels of difficulty
Reactive control with game controller
Possible chapter replays before the end of the story.
A very good mafia story...
Many things to collect and unlock in the world...
A good pace in the countryside
Well-written dialogues and cinematically staged intermediate sequences.
Cover shooting battles with a good dose of punch
Spectacular hunting/chase sequences
Stealth mechanics and knife combat increase the diversity of gameplay.
Very good graphics, often photorealistic with many details and a great draw distance (PC)
Actors digitized by motion capture and performance capture
Mainly first-class character animations with fine facial expressiveness.
Atmospheric and catchy original soundtrack, propelling the fight.
Rich and often realistic sound effects
Several language options available on board, including a good synchronization in German.
... even if partly predictable
"Open world" is in itself just a simple (beautiful) backdrop.
Conservative game design up to outdated
KI in incompetent Stealth point
Many graphical bugs, but almost exclusively of small size.
The cutscenes also run on PC with a maximum of 30 frames per second.
The sound in the German version is a bit too loud.
[8/10] reviewed at 07/08/2025 - Test+: Mafia - The Old Country...[read the full review on GamersGlobal]
8
10

Checkpoint Gaming
Stunning Sicilian worldbuilding
Deep, character-driven storytelling
Authentic voice acting and culture
Strong visual and art direction
Memorable missions and set-pieces
Basic combat and stealth
Underwritten women and predictable beats
[8/10] reviewed at 07/08/2025 - Test Mafia: The Old Country ? Blood and beauty...[read the full review on Checkpoint Gaming]
8
10

GamingBolt
Great storytelling, Excellent character development, Strong voice acting and production values, Solid set pieces, Combat and stealth mechanics are simple but effective
Abrupt transition in story towards the end, Limited Replay Value
[8/10] reviewed at 07/08/2025 - Test Mafia: The Old Country ? A Gangster Epic That Respects Your Time...[read the full review on GamingBolt]
8
10

Vandal
[8/10] reviewed at 08/08/2025 - Mafia: The Old Country - Análisis...[read the full review on Vandal]
8
10

Journal du Geek
[8/10] reviewed at 11/08/2025 - Test Mafia The Old Country : la licence de retour au sommet ?...[read the full review on Journal du Geek]
8
10

GameOver
[8/10] reviewed at 11/08/2025 - Test Mafia: The Old Country |...[read the full review on GameOver]
8
10

Xbox-Mag
[8/10] reviewed at 12/08/2025 - Test de Mafia: The Old Country sur Xbox Series X, le doux retour aux sources...[read the full review on Xbox-Mag]
4
5

TheXboxHub
Beautiful visuals
Great sound
Fun and thrilling driving
Exciting set pieces
Needs a more open world
Too many knife fights
[4/5] reviewed at 13/08/2025 - Test Mafia: The Old Country...[read the full review on TheXboxHub]
4
5

N-Gamz
[4/5] reviewed at 16/08/2025 - Mafia The Old Country : Test Vidéo PS5 Pro ! Superbe retour aux sources ?...[read the full review on N-Gamz]
75
100

JVFrance
A true dive into the Italian Mafia
Very beautiful graphically
An excellent French version
An interesting and captivating story
An incredible soundtrack
An anecdotal exploration
Way too many infiltration phases
A gameplay that is not very revolutionary
A repetitive gameplay loop
Some optimization problems
[75/100] reviewed at 07/08/2025 - TEST Mafia: The Old Country ? Un digne héritier sous pression...[read the full review on JVFrance]
15
20

GamerGen
[15/20] reviewed at 01/01/1970 - TEST Mafia: The Old Country, la Sicile en habits de gangster...[read the full review on GamerGen]
72
100

Fortress Of Solitude
Riveting storyline and compelling characters
It feels like you're in Sicily in the 1900s
The promise of open world is deceptive
The gameplay is from the 1900s
[72/100] reviewed at 18/08/2025 - Test Mafia: The Old Country ? An Old-School Throwback For Better or Worse...[read the full review on Fortress Of Solitude]
7
10

GameKult.com
A classic plot, but very effective
A very good gallery of characters
The dubbing in Sicilian is of very good quality.
An open world in the Mafia style, a bit empty, but very beautiful to explore.
Some minor (but not harmful) technical issues
An outdated gameplay and an AI that needs to be reviewed
Phases of infiltration that are way too easy
[7/10] reviewed at 07/08/2025 - Test : Mafia : The Old Country, une histoire intemporelle, mais un gameplay daté...[read the full review on GameKult.com]
7
10

Multiplayer.it
A solo adventure, linear and with a well-told story.
There is everything one would expect from an action game with open world elements.
Excellent soundtrack and the dubbing in Sicilian is a great discovery.
The graphic design, especially for the characters, is sometimes remarkable.
All gameplay mechanics are derived and basic.
Knife duels quickly become repetitive.
Some minor technical issues related to youth
Someone could complain about the lack of a "traditional" Italian dubbing.
[7/10] reviewed at 07/08/2025 - Mafia: Terra Madre, la recensione della nuova avventura action ambientata in Sicilia...[read the full review on Multiplayer.it]
7
10

Hinsusta
[7/10] reviewed at 08/08/2025 - Mafia: The Old Country ? Im Test (PC)...[read the full review on Hinsusta]
7
10

Xbox Tavern
[7/10] reviewed at 11/08/2025 - Test Mafia: The Old Country...[read the full review on Xbox Tavern]
7
10

Movies Games and Tech
[7/10] reviewed at 12/08/2025 - Review: Mafia: The Old Country...[read the full review on Movies Games and Tech]
7
10

Numerama
[7/10] reviewed at 12/08/2025 - On a fini Mafia: The Old Country, et c'est un vrai amour de vacances...[read the full review on Numerama]
7
10

Pizza Fria
[7/10] reviewed at 12/08/2025 - Mafia: The Old Country | Review...[read the full review on Pizza Fria]
70
100

Console Tribe
[70/100] reviewed at 14/08/2025 - Mafia: Terra Madre - Recensione...[read the full review on Console Tribe]
70
100

Complete Xbox
A well-written and strong storyline throughout
The Sicilian environment is rich in detail and stunningly presented
10-15 hour campaign, which is great if you?re a fan of shorter playthroughs
Fantastic voice acting and great cutscenes
Combat is underwhelming and clunky
Stealth scenes are easy, and AI barely reacts
Whilst the game certainly looks nice, the visuals are dated
The most linear experience in the franchise
[70/100] reviewed at 14/08/2025 - Test Mafia: The Old Country...[read the full review on Complete Xbox]
7
10

VideoChums
[7/10] reviewed at 15/08/2025 - Test Mafia: The Old Country...[read the full review on VideoChums]
7
10

GameHope
[7/10] reviewed at 18/08/2025 - Mafia : The Old Country (Xbox Series)...[read the full review on GameHope]
[7/10] reviewed at 18/08/2025 - Mafia : The Old Country (PS5)...[read the full review on GameHope]
[7/10] reviewed at 18/08/2025 - Mafia : The Old Country (PC)...[read the full review on GameHope]
6
10

GameSpot
[6/10] reviewed at 07/08/2025 - Test Mafia: The Old Country - Look But Don't Touch...[read the full review on GameSpot]
6
10

GameReactor
Great action sequences
Stylish setting
Good voice actors and music
Slow start
Unimaginative missions
Poor mix of open and linear design
[6/10] reviewed at 07/08/2025 - Mafia: The Old Country...[read the full review on GameReactor]
6
10

GameInformer
[6/10] reviewed at 07/08/2025 - Test Mafia: The Old Country ? An Offer You Can Probably Refuse...[read the full review on GameInformer]
6
10

Push Square
[6/10] reviewed at 11/08/2025 - Review: Mafia: The Old Country (PS5) - Historical Crime Story Runs Out of Ammo...[read the full review on Push Square]
3
5

EuroGamer.fr
[3/5] reviewed at 13/08/2025 - Test Mafia: The Old Country...[read the full review on EuroGamer.fr]
6
10

ActuGaming
[6/10] reviewed at 17/08/2025 - Test Mafia : The Old Country ? Un retour dans le passé, mais pas uniquement narratif...[read the full review on ActuGaming]
4
10

Well Played
[4/10] reviewed at 18/08/2025 - Test Mafia: The Old Country...[read the full review on Well Played]
-

hyNerd.it
[/] reviewed at 21/08/2024 - Mafia: The Old Country è la Nuova Aggiunta alla Serie di Mafia. Gamescom 2024...[read the full review on hyNerd.it]
-

Gaming Trend
Narrative is absolutely brilliant
Voice cast nails the assignment
Visually-stunning world and cutscenes
Horse and car navigation is top-notch
That ending
Open-world lacks substance in Explore mode
A few bugs
[/] reviewed at 07/08/2025 - Test Mafia: The Old Country ? An offer I can't refuse...[read the full review on Gaming Trend]
-

GeekCulture
[/] reviewed at 07/08/2025 - Test Mafia: The Old Country ?...[read the full review on GeekCulture]
-

TierraGamer
[/] reviewed at 07/08/2025 - Mafia: The Old Country una odisea criminal que nos lleva al pasado en más de un aspecto...[read the full review on TierraGamer]
-

JeuxVideo.com
[/] reviewed at 07/08/2025 - Test Mafia : The Old Country sur PC, PS5 et Xbox Series...[read the full review on JeuxVideo.com]
[/] reviewed at 15/08/2025 - Mafia The Old Country tue dans le respect des traditions : 10 minutes pour tout comprendre, notre test en vidéo...[read the full review on JeuxVideo.com]
-

GamesWelt
A strong atmosphere and a convincing mafia setting.
Successful character development and narrative density
beautiful environments, authentic atmosphere of Sicily
Exciting and surprising knife fights with a boss battle feel.
Solid shooting game, classic cover mechanics
Optional exploration, unlockable bonuses
technically with some weaknesses (jerky movements, necessary restarts)
Some parts of the story are somewhat cliché.
Gestures, synchronization, and dialogues are not always successful.
few playful ideas, only superficial stealth
[/] reviewed at 07/08/2025 - Mafia: The Old Country - Test: Schnörkelloses, opulentes Mafia-Drama...[read the full review on GamesWelt]
-

Computer Bild
[/] reviewed at 08/08/2025 - Mafia: The Old Country im Test ? atmosphärische Gangster-Action!...[read the full review on Computer Bild]
-

ComputerBase
[/] reviewed at 12/08/2025 - Mafia: The Old Country im Test: Grafikkarten-Benchmarks mit extrem hohen Anforderungen...[read the full review on ComputerBase]
-

Xboxygen
[/] reviewed at 12/08/2025 - Test - Mafia : The Old Country - une lettre d'amour pantouflarde...[read the full review on Xboxygen]
-

TestingBuddies
[/] reviewed at 11/08/2025 - Mafia: The Old Country im Test: Zurück in der Familie...[read the full review on TestingBuddies]
-

Game-eXperience.it
[/] reviewed at 14/08/2025 - Mafia: Terra Madre, la recensione: amuninni 2K!...[read the full review on Game-eXperience.it]
-

CowCotLand.com
[/] reviewed at 14/08/2025 - Mafia: The Old Country : quel GPU intégrera la famille ?...[read the full review on CowCotLand.com]
-

Beyond Gaming
[/] reviewed at 15/08/2025 - Review: Mafia: The Old Country...[read the full review on Beyond Gaming]

Users & Customers reviews for Mafia The Old Country

(affiliate links)

amazon.com

check availability
instant-gaming

Reviews of youtubers about Mafia The Old Country

We find these video-Reviews & tests on youtube about Mafia The Old Country

Videos Tests Mafia The Old Country Mafia The Old Country at the best price !
Mafia: The Old Country - Review After 100%
Mafia: The Old Country Review

Reviews of others Video Games Mafia

Test Mafia 2, Test Mafia Definitive Edition, Test Mafia II: Definitive Edition,
... and find all reviews find for brand Mafia

Reviews listed above are from hyNerd.it, PCGames, GameKult.com, GameSpot, wccftech, JVFrance, GameReactor, Gaming Trend, GameInformer, GamersGlobal, GeekCulture, Areajugones, Generación Xbox, Multiplayer.it, Checkpoint Gaming, Games.ch, TierraGamer, JeuxVideo.com, GamesWelt, GamingBolt, Computer Bild, Vandal, Hinsusta, MKAU Gaming, Journal du Geek, TechPowerUp, COGconnected, Push Square, Xbox Tavern, GameOver, Movies Games and Tech, ComputerBase, Numerama, Xbox-Mag, Xboxygen, Pizza Fria, EuroGamer.fr, TheXboxHub, TestingBuddies, Game-eXperience.it, Console Tribe, CowCotLand.com, Complete Xbox, VideoChums, Beyond Gaming, N-Gamz, GamerGen, ActuGaming, Well Played, GameHope, Fortress Of Solitude,

Your review and rating for Mafia The Old Country: