<< latest reviews
3.4
5
32 ratings

Madden NFL 24 Review: 35 Ratings, Pros and Cons

Date: (Last saved review: ) -

Check all the 35 reviews find on Video Games Madden NFL 24, with the 32 ratings, comments, pros & cons from the reviewers.
Theses reviews and tests from Video Games magazines and websites give 32 ratings, we get this average rating to this Madden NFL product : 3.4/5.
Madden NFL 24 review : Madden NFL 24 seems to be good in the Video Games category, so overall reviews are positive for this product.


For Video Games, ratings are sometimes different depending on the platform. Please refer to the good review...

Madden NFL 24 ratings

32 Ratings ranked from best to worst, green to good grades, red to bad, Average rating: 3.4/5
8.5/10 TestingBuddies
8.5/10 MKAU Gaming
4/5 Outerhaven Productions
8/10 PlayStation LifeStyle
4/5 Hardcore Gamer
8/10 Phenixx Gaming
7.8/10 Xbox Tavern
7.6/10 Pixel
7.5/10 Pizza Fria
7.5/10 SerialGamer
7.2/10 The Games Machine
7/10 GamingBolt
70/100 COGconnected
70/100 MeuPlayStation
70/100 Windows Central
3.5/5 GodIsAGeek
7/10 Push Square
7/10 ZTGD
70/100 Complete Xbox
6.75/10 GameInformer
6.7/10 GamesVillage
6.7/10 NerdMovieProductions
65/100 Gaming Trend
6/10 XBoxEra
6/10 TheSixthAxis
3/5 Twinfinite
6/10 GameReactor
6/10 Beyond Gaming
6/10 Shacknews
3/5 TheXboxHub
2/5 GamesRadar
4/10 Niche Gamer
Preview or review without rating: Tech Princess, Chalgyr's Game Room, CoupleOfGamer

Pros and cons for Madden NFL 24 List of reviews and ratings

To better compare, we looked for you the advantages and disadvantages of Below and the notes given by specialized sites.

8.5
10

TestingBuddies
[8.5/10] reviewed at 23/08/2023 - Madden NFL 24 im Test ? EA schickt uns in die neue Season...[read the full review on TestingBuddies]
8.5
10

MKAU Gaming
Commentary Team were utterly amazing
Awesome gameplay
Hyper-realistic graphics
Exciting music and sounds
Graphical glitches during cutscenes
[8.5/10] reviewed at 28/08/2023 - Test Madden NFL 24 (Xbox Series X) ?...[read the full review on MKAU Gaming]
4
5

Outerhaven Productions
Excellent graphics and animations
Smoothest gameplay in years
Online works great
Lots to do
Clunky, slow menus
Ultimate Team can be a grind
New control options can be confusing
Lots to do
[4/5] reviewed at 21/08/2023 - Test Madden NFL 24 ? Hall of Fame bound?One Day...[read the full review on Outerhaven Productions]
8
10

PlayStation LifeStyle
[8/10] reviewed at 21/08/2023 - Test Madden NFL 24: Superstar Showdown Mode Shines...[read the full review on PlayStation LifeStyle]
4
5

Hardcore Gamer
[4/5] reviewed at 21/08/2023 - Review: Madden NFL 24...[read the full review on Hardcore Gamer]
8
10

Phenixx Gaming
FieldSENSE animations are pristine
Game looks and feels smoother
Superstar Mode has some nice additions
An incremental year of improvements, not a huge leap
Tiny frustrations persist in-game
[8/10] reviewed at 28/08/2023 - Test Madden 24 (Xbox Series X)...[read the full review on Phenixx Gaming]
7.8
10

Xbox Tavern
Massive improvement over last year
Stunning looking visuals
Superstar mode makes a welcome return
AI still makes questionable decisions even with the new system
Ultimate Team is still overly saturated
[7.8/10] reviewed at 22/08/2023 - Test Madden NFL 24...[read the full review on Xbox Tavern]
7.6
10

Pixel
Superstar Mode with NFL Combine
Realist movements
mini-games
Slow user interface
Overall, there is still room for improvement.
[7.6/10] reviewed at 23/08/2023 - Madden NFL 24 im Test ? Ein Schritt nach vorne?...[read the full review on Pixel]
7.5
10

Pizza Fria
The immersion continues to be even better and more detailed.
The Superstar mode is the major innovation of this edition.
New technologies are good, even if they do not have a big impact.
The game has still not been localized in Brazilian Portuguese.
The menus still have the same bugs and crashes as in previous editions.
The price of the game is very high for the Brazilian public.
[7.5/10] reviewed at 01/09/2023 - EA SPORTS Madden NFL 24 | Review...[read the full review on Pizza Fria]
7.5
10

SerialGamer
Animation management
Attack phases
Defense to recalibrate
Artificial intelligence
[7.5/10] reviewed at 08/09/2023 - Madden NFL 24: un touchdown conservativo ? Recensione...[read the full review on SerialGamer]
7.2
10

The Games Machine
Enriched animation compartment at every phase of the game.
Managing the attack effectively
Defense artificial intelligence to be recalibrated
[7.2/10] reviewed at 25/08/2023 - Madden NFL 24 ? Recensione...[read the full review on The Games Machine]
7
10

GamingBolt
Excellent graphics
Improved animations
More skill-based controls and manoeuvrability.
Some undercooked minigames
Added (and some returning) elements with less functional impact such as Team Relocation
Occasional unrefined offensive running play mechanics
A lack of any truly impactful additions to the overall package in favor of making smaller improvements.
[7/10] reviewed at 23/08/2023 - Test Madden NFL 24 ? Another 5-Yard Gain...[read the full review on GamingBolt]
70
100

COGconnected
Silky smooth gameplay
Superstar mode is addictive
Animations don?t repeat much
Franchise mode is complete
Soundtrack stinks
Lack of innovation
Madden plays it safe
MUT UI glitchy
[70/100] reviewed at 24/08/2023 - Test Madden NFL 24 ? No Frills Football...[read the full review on COGconnected]
70
100

MeuPlayStation
The passes and gameplay in general seem better.
Superstar is back in a big way and is the biggest attraction.
The Franchise mode has good news.
The new player animations are really cool.
The menus continue to be extremely slow.
Several visual bugs during the games.
There is no team creation tool.
Playing in Brazil remains a great challenge.
The graphics and presentation have not evolved.
[70/100] reviewed at 25/08/2023 - Madden NFL 24: vale a pena?...[read the full review on MeuPlayStation]
70
100

Windows Central
Animation and AI changes are great
Improved visuals continue to make this the most realistic football product
Return of minigames is a nice touch
Menu navigation feels shockingly slow and clumsy
Changes not enough to stop the game from feeling stale
[70/100] reviewed at 27/08/2023 - Test Madden NFL 24: A technically solid, technically unambitious entry...[read the full review on Windows Central]
3.5
5

GodIsAGeek
Fantastic animations
Great additions to how it plays
Attention to player sizes are welcomed
Menus are slow
Some modes lack much improvement
[3.5/5] reviewed at 28/08/2023 - Test Madden NFL 24...[read the full review on GodIsAGeek]
7
10

Push Square
Tons of new animations
Crossplay works well
Gameplay feels fluid
Ultimate Team has a better flow
Sluggish menus grate
Microtransactions still exist
Doesn't do enough new
[7/10] reviewed at 28/08/2023 - Review: Madden NFL 24 (PS5) - Another Five Yards Forward for EA Sports' Football Sim...[read the full review on Push Square]
7
10

ZTGD
New animations are fantastic
Franchise improvements
Most modes are untouched
Drops, drops, drops
Framerate issues in between plays
[7/10] reviewed at 29/08/2023 - Test Madden NFL 24 (XSX)...[read the full review on ZTGD]
70
100

Complete Xbox
Superstar Mode.
Closer to the real thing than ever before.
SAPIEN Technology gives players real identity.
Tiptoes towards change rather than taking strides.
Input delay.
Performance issues.
[70/100] reviewed at 29/08/2023 - Test Madden 24...[read the full review on Complete Xbox]
6.75
10

GameInformer
[6.75/10] reviewed at 21/08/2023 - Test Madden NFL 24 - Unnecessary Roughness...[read the full review on GameInformer]
6.7
10

GamesVillage
[6.7/10] reviewed at 04/09/2023 - Madden NFL 24 Recensione: ritorna il football americano, ma con poche novità...[read the full review on GamesVillage]
6.7
10

NerdMovieProductions
FieldSENSE and SAPIEN technology offer a quality gaming experience.
The Franchise modality remains amusing.
Excellent soundtrack
The terms and conditions have been copy-pasted for too many years.
The progression of the series is too slow.
Too many bugs and glitches.
[6.7/10] reviewed at 21/09/2023 - Madden NFL 24, La Recensione...[read the full review on NerdMovieProductions]
65
100

Gaming Trend
Mini-Games are back and play amazingly
Additions to Franchise Mode are fun and make the game more realistic
Sapien Technology makes the players, in general, look amazing
Glitches, glitches, and more glitches
Lacking attention to detail
MUT continues to be Pay-To-Win unless you have time for all solo missions
[65/100] reviewed at 23/08/2023 - Test Madden NFL 24 ? Time is against Madden NFL...[read the full review on Gaming Trend]
6
10

XBoxEra
Strong gameplay and simulation mechanics.
Lots of modes of play to choose from.
Good visuals and animations are top-notch.
User experience and menus are unintuitive and really slow, affecting some of the game's pillar modes.
Tutorials aren't the best. Players new to American Football will easily feel bogged down.
[6/10] reviewed at 18/08/2023 - Review | Madden NFL 24 (Xbox Series)...[read the full review on XBoxEra]
6
10

TheSixthAxis
SAPIEN technology is a huge step forward
TV-style presentation is excellent
Return of mini-games is very welcome
Hampered by bugs and hard crashes
Unrealistic stats appear regularly in franchise mode
Play modes are very similar to last year
[6/10] reviewed at 21/08/2023 - Test Madden 24...[read the full review on TheSixthAxis]
3
5

Twinfinite
[3/5] reviewed at 21/08/2023 - Test Madden 24 ? Don't Forget You're Here Forever...[read the full review on Twinfinite]
6
10

GameReactor
New and improved animations. Players in certain positions have been made better. Still fun to play on the pitch. Tackles that are felt in your bones.
Slightly buggy. Too little new content. Computer players can be dumb. Really wants to make you spend money in the game.
[6/10] reviewed at 29/08/2023 - Madden NFL 24...[read the full review on GameReactor]
6
10

Beyond Gaming
More visually aesthetic
FieldSENSE seems to enhance the gaming experience.
More control over throws and tackles.
Mini-games!
Bugs and crashes
The menus are incredibly slow.
Creating avatars is annoying with caricature-like results.
Wait and see if the honeymoon lasts.
[6/10] reviewed at 01/09/2023 - Review: Madden NFL 24...[read the full review on Beyond Gaming]
6
10

Shacknews
Improved knockout and tackle animations
Quality-of-life improvements to Franchise mode
Crossplay is finally here
Madden Ultimate Team is still a microtransaction farm
Menu navigation is slow and clunky
Same bugs from last year
Superstar mode fails to reach potential
[6/10] reviewed at 01/01/1970 - Madden NFL 24 review: Inching forward...[read the full review on Shacknews]
3
5

TheXboxHub
Excellent on-field action
SAPIEN Tech and FieldSENSE make a noticeable improvement
Archaic menus
MUT and Superstar modes are very shallow
Returning minigames quickly become stale
[3/5] reviewed at 10/09/2023 - Test Madden NFL 24...[read the full review on TheXboxHub]
2
5

GamesRadar
+
Improved visuals, from lighting to textures
-
Glacially slow improvements continue year-to-year
-
Sluggish menu navigation and familiar glitches
-
It's just the same damn Madden we've played for a decade
[2/5] reviewed at 23/08/2023 - Test Madden 24: "A clumsy, rickety game of pro football"...[read the full review on GamesRadar]
4
10

Niche Gamer
Updated Rosters
New precision throwing system
Return of the Camp Mini Games
new cross platform gameplay
Horrible soundtrack
bare minimum graphics updates
lacks accessibility options
Carbon copy of its former self
Variety of bugs that kill the experience
[4/10] reviewed at 26/09/2023 - Test Madden 24 ? An Attempted NFL Sim...[read the full review on Niche Gamer]
-

Tech Princess
Player animations
Graphics and camera movements
Vasto playbook translates to "vast playbook" in English.
No substantial changes compared to the 2023 edition.
Loading screenshots
Playability
Realism
[/] reviewed at 28/08/2023 - Madden NFL 24 rappresenta l'ennesimo fallimento dei videogiochi sportivi ? La recensione...[read the full review on Tech Princess]
-

Chalgyr's Game Room
[/] reviewed at 28/08/2023 - Madden NFL 24 Review...[read the full review on Chalgyr's Game Room]
-

CoupleOfGamer
[/] reviewed at 29/08/2023 - [Test][PlayStation 5] Madden NFL 24...[read the full review on CoupleOfGamer]

Users & Customers reviews for Madden NFL 24

(affiliate links)

amazon.com

check availability
instant-gaming
not rated yet
amazon.fr

5/5
scored by 4 users

Reviews of youtubers about Madden NFL 24

We find these video-Reviews & tests on youtube about Madden NFL 24

Videos Tests Madden NFL 24 Madden NFL 24 at the best price !

Reviews of others Video Games Madden NFL

Test Madden NFL 23, Test Madden NFL 22, Test Madden NFL 21,
... and find all reviews find for brand Madden NFL

Reviews listed above are from XBoxEra, TheSixthAxis, Outerhaven Productions, GameInformer, PlayStation LifeStyle, Hardcore Gamer, Xbox Tavern, GamesRadar, GamingBolt, Gaming Trend, Pixel, TestingBuddies, COGconnected, The Games Machine, MeuPlayStation, Windows Central, GodIsAGeek, MKAU Gaming, Tech Princess, Chalgyr's Game Room, Push Square, Twinfinite, Phenixx Gaming, CoupleOfGamer, GameReactor, ZTGD, Complete Xbox, Beyond Gaming, Pizza Fria, GamesVillage, Shacknews, TheXboxHub, NerdMovieProductions, Niche Gamer, SerialGamer,

Your review and rating for Madden NFL 24: